Valentin Vidic
2018-Jan-12 11:43 UTC
[Pkg-xen-devel] Bug#880554: xen domu freezes with kernel linux-image-4.9.0-4-amd64
On Fri, Jan 12, 2018 at 01:34:10AM +0100, Hans van Kranenburg wrote:> Is the 59 your lots-o-vcpu-monster?Yes, that is the one with a larger vcpu count.> I just finished with the initial preparation of a Xen 4.10 package for > unstable and have it running in my test environment.Unrelated to this issue, but can you tell me if there is a way to mitigate Meltdown with the Xen 4.8 dom0/domU(PV) running stretch?> Since this has been reported multiple times already, and upstream has > bumped it to 64, my verdict would be: > > * Bump default to 64 already like upstream did in a later version. > * Properly document this issue in NEWS.Debian and also mention the > option with documentation in the template grub config file, so there's a > bigger chance users who run unusual big numbers of disks/nics/cpus/etc > will find it. > > ...so we also better accomodate users who are using newer kernels in the > domU with blk-mq, and prevent them from wasting too much time and > getting frustrated for no reason. > > I wouldn't be comfortable with bumping it above the current latest > greatest upstream default, since it would mean we would need to keep a > patch in later versions. > > I'll prepare a patch to bump the default to 64 in 4.8, taking changes > from the upstream patch. I probably have to ask upstream (Juergen Gross) > why the commit that was referenced earlier bumps the default without > mentioning it in the commit message.Thanks, 64 should be a good start. If there are still problems reported with that it can be reconsidered. -- Valentin