thr3ads.net - openssh unix dev - Confusion using "ssh-add -D" and then "ssh-add -l" [Oct 2024]

If this information is useful, please help other people find it:
Share via:

Chris Green

2024-Oct-18 10:38 UTC

Confusion using "ssh-add -D" and then "ssh-add -l"

I'm confused by the following:-

    rcfg at q957$  ssh-add -l
    256 SHA256:gl9l9m/xnYpL9P7WkL60L+FcJ0+r2c5Ci770p9VEC08 chris at q957
(ED25519)
    256 SHA256:4XDYbepg8zK43pofpQ8IGxMAXkej298a0XZHWjJTIQQ chris at q957
(ED25519)
    3072 SHA256:yeQw8xe9rrxHKLqICoXNwReZKKV9HI1UeTCf95QywXM chris at t470 (RSA)
    256 SHA256:dluRgJeTqJ32jKxRrSdjr/cibbIOZQeq8Inlna3+Sdw chris at q957
(ED25519)
    3072 SHA256:dJws+ny7+uWMo2hwFl6yNGE5vFsW1ZKiO0EXwTIfNPc chris at t470 (RSA)
    256 SHA256:BxqEiksrCXPxKvQyBXqOqw1WKda110lYiC00Z+fKP4A chris at q957
(ED25519)
    rcfg at q957$ ssh-add -D
    All identities removed.
    rcfg at q957$ ssh-add -l
    256 SHA256:4XDYbepg8zK43pofpQ8IGxMAXkej298a0XZHWjJTIQQ chris at q957
(ED25519)
    3072 SHA256:yeQw8xe9rrxHKLqICoXNwReZKKV9HI1UeTCf95QywXM chris at t470 (RSA)
    256 SHA256:dluRgJeTqJ32jKxRrSdjr/cibbIOZQeq8Inlna3+Sdw chris at q957
(ED25519)
    256 SHA256:gl9l9m/xnYpL9P7WkL60L+FcJ0+r2c5Ci770p9VEC08 chris at q957
(ED25519)
    3072 SHA256:dJws+ny7+uWMo2hwFl6yNGE5vFsW1ZKiO0EXwTIfNPc chris at t470 (RSA)
    256 SHA256:BxqEiksrCXPxKvQyBXqOqw1WKda110lYiC00Z+fKP4A chris at q957
(ED25519)
    rcfg at q957$ 

What's going on here?  I was expecting all the entries to disappear,
but they don't.

I checked when reverting to my default 'chris' login with
$HOME=/home/chris but it's exactly the same:-

    chris$ ssh-add -l
    256 SHA256:4XDYbepg8zK43pofpQ8IGxMAXkej298a0XZHWjJTIQQ chris at q957
(ED25519)
    3072 SHA256:yeQw8xe9rrxHKLqICoXNwReZKKV9HI1UeTCf95QywXM chris at t470 (RSA)
    256 SHA256:dluRgJeTqJ32jKxRrSdjr/cibbIOZQeq8Inlna3+Sdw chris at q957
(ED25519)
    256 SHA256:gl9l9m/xnYpL9P7WkL60L+FcJ0+r2c5Ci770p9VEC08 chris at q957
(ED25519)
    3072 SHA256:dJws+ny7+uWMo2hwFl6yNGE5vFsW1ZKiO0EXwTIfNPc chris at t470 (RSA)
    256 SHA256:BxqEiksrCXPxKvQyBXqOqw1WKda110lYiC00Z+fKP4A chris at q957
(ED25519)
    chris$ ssh-add -D
    All identities removed.
    chris$ ssh-add -l
    256 SHA256:4XDYbepg8zK43pofpQ8IGxMAXkej298a0XZHWjJTIQQ chris at q957
(ED25519)
    3072 SHA256:yeQw8xe9rrxHKLqICoXNwReZKKV9HI1UeTCf95QywXM chris at t470 (RSA)
    256 SHA256:dluRgJeTqJ32jKxRrSdjr/cibbIOZQeq8Inlna3+Sdw chris at q957
(ED25519)
    256 SHA256:gl9l9m/xnYpL9P7WkL60L+FcJ0+r2c5Ci770p9VEC08 chris at q957
(ED25519)
    3072 SHA256:dJws+ny7+uWMo2hwFl6yNGE5vFsW1ZKiO0EXwTIfNPc chris at t470 (RSA)
    256 SHA256:BxqEiksrCXPxKvQyBXqOqw1WKda110lYiC00Z+fKP4A chris at q957
(ED25519)
    chris$ 

I guess I'm misunderstanding something but I don't see what at the
moment.


-- 
Chris Green

Chris Green

2024-Oct-18 11:50 UTC

head link

Confusion using "ssh-add -D" and then "ssh-add -l"

On Fri, Oct 18, 2024 at 11:38:37AM +0100, Chris Green
wrote:> I'm confused by the following:-
> 
>     rcfg at q957$  ssh-add -l
>     256 SHA256:gl9l9m/xnYpL9P7WkL60L+FcJ0+r2c5Ci770p9VEC08 chris at q957
(ED25519)
>     256 SHA256:4XDYbepg8zK43pofpQ8IGxMAXkej298a0XZHWjJTIQQ chris at q957
(ED25519)
>     3072 SHA256:yeQw8xe9rrxHKLqICoXNwReZKKV9HI1UeTCf95QywXM chris at t470
(RSA)
>     256 SHA256:dluRgJeTqJ32jKxRrSdjr/cibbIOZQeq8Inlna3+Sdw chris at q957
(ED25519)
>     3072 SHA256:dJws+ny7+uWMo2hwFl6yNGE5vFsW1ZKiO0EXwTIfNPc chris at t470
(RSA)
>     256 SHA256:BxqEiksrCXPxKvQyBXqOqw1WKda110lYiC00Z+fKP4A chris at q957
(ED25519)
>     rcfg at q957$ ssh-add -D
>     All identities removed.
>     rcfg at q957$ ssh-add -l
>     256 SHA256:4XDYbepg8zK43pofpQ8IGxMAXkej298a0XZHWjJTIQQ chris at q957
(ED25519)
>     3072 SHA256:yeQw8xe9rrxHKLqICoXNwReZKKV9HI1UeTCf95QywXM chris at t470
(RSA)
>     256 SHA256:dluRgJeTqJ32jKxRrSdjr/cibbIOZQeq8Inlna3+Sdw chris at q957
(ED25519)
>     256 SHA256:gl9l9m/xnYpL9P7WkL60L+FcJ0+r2c5Ci770p9VEC08 chris at q957
(ED25519)
>     3072 SHA256:dJws+ny7+uWMo2hwFl6yNGE5vFsW1ZKiO0EXwTIfNPc chris at t470
(RSA)
>     256 SHA256:BxqEiksrCXPxKvQyBXqOqw1WKda110lYiC00Z+fKP4A chris at q957
(ED25519)
>     rcfg at q957$ 
> 
> What's going on here?  I was expecting all the entries to disappear,
> but they don't.
> 
> I checked when reverting to my default 'chris' login with
> $HOME=/home/chris but it's exactly the same:-
> 
>     chris$ ssh-add -l
>     256 SHA256:4XDYbepg8zK43pofpQ8IGxMAXkej298a0XZHWjJTIQQ chris at q957
(ED25519)
>     3072 SHA256:yeQw8xe9rrxHKLqICoXNwReZKKV9HI1UeTCf95QywXM chris at t470
(RSA)
>     256 SHA256:dluRgJeTqJ32jKxRrSdjr/cibbIOZQeq8Inlna3+Sdw chris at q957
(ED25519)
>     256 SHA256:gl9l9m/xnYpL9P7WkL60L+FcJ0+r2c5Ci770p9VEC08 chris at q957
(ED25519)
>     3072 SHA256:dJws+ny7+uWMo2hwFl6yNGE5vFsW1ZKiO0EXwTIfNPc chris at t470
(RSA)
>     256 SHA256:BxqEiksrCXPxKvQyBXqOqw1WKda110lYiC00Z+fKP4A chris at q957
(ED25519)
>     chris$ ssh-add -D
>     All identities removed.
>     chris$ ssh-add -l
>     256 SHA256:4XDYbepg8zK43pofpQ8IGxMAXkej298a0XZHWjJTIQQ chris at q957
(ED25519)
>     3072 SHA256:yeQw8xe9rrxHKLqICoXNwReZKKV9HI1UeTCf95QywXM chris at t470
(RSA)
>     256 SHA256:dluRgJeTqJ32jKxRrSdjr/cibbIOZQeq8Inlna3+Sdw chris at q957
(ED25519)
>     256 SHA256:gl9l9m/xnYpL9P7WkL60L+FcJ0+r2c5Ci770p9VEC08 chris at q957
(ED25519)
>     3072 SHA256:dJws+ny7+uWMo2hwFl6yNGE5vFsW1ZKiO0EXwTIfNPc chris at t470
(RSA)
>     256 SHA256:BxqEiksrCXPxKvQyBXqOqw1WKda110lYiC00Z+fKP4A chris at q957
(ED25519)
>     chris$ 
> 
> I guess I'm misunderstanding something but I don't see what at the
moment.
> 
> Probably related to the same problem:-

    chris$ ssh-add /home/chris/.share/rcfg/.ssh/rcfgKey
    Enter passphrase for /home/chris/.share/rcfg/.ssh/rcfgKey: 
    Identity added: /home/chris/.share/rcfg/.ssh/rcfgKey (root at q957)
    chris$ ssh -i /home/chris/.share/rcfg/.ssh/rcfgKey root at backup
    Enter passphrase for key '/home/chris/.share/rcfg/.ssh/rcfgKey': 
    root at backup:~# 


Hmm, I think there's something funny going on with the ssh-agent
socket:-

    chris$ ps -fe | grep ssh-agent
    chris       2463    1530  0 12:33 ?        00:00:00 /usr/bin/ssh-agent -D -a
/run/user/1000/keyring/.ssh

but:-

    chris$ env | grep SSH
    SSH_AUTH_SOCK=/run/user/1000/keyring/ssh

So SSH_AUTH_SOCK doesn't appear to be the socket that ssh-agent thinks
it should be.

This is on a fairly standard/default xubuntu 24.04 installation, I've
not played about with the agent stuff (or at least I don't think I
have).

Both the sockets exist:-

    chris$ ls -al /run/user/1000/keyring/
    total 0
    drwx------  2 chris chris 120 Oct 18 12:33 .
    drwx------ 13 chris chris 420 Oct 18 12:32 ..
    srw-------  1 chris chris   0 Oct 18 12:33 .ssh
    srw-rw-rw-  1 chris chris   0 Oct 18 12:32 control
    srwxrwxr-x  1 chris chris   0 Oct 18 12:32 pkcs11
    srwxrwxr-x  1 chris chris   0 Oct 18 12:32 ssh

Can anyone suggest what might be awry?


-- 
Chris Green

Brian Candler

2024-Oct-18 11:52 UTC

head link

Confusion using "ssh-add -D" and then "ssh-add -l"

On 18/10/2024 11:38, Chris Green wrote:>      chris$ ssh-add -l
>      256 SHA256:4XDYbepg8zK43pofpQ8IGxMAXkej298a0XZHWjJTIQQ chris at q957
(ED25519)
>      3072 SHA256:yeQw8xe9rrxHKLqICoXNwReZKKV9HI1UeTCf95QywXM chris at t470
(RSA)
>      256 SHA256:dluRgJeTqJ32jKxRrSdjr/cibbIOZQeq8Inlna3+Sdw chris at q957
(ED25519)
>      256 SHA256:gl9l9m/xnYpL9P7WkL60L+FcJ0+r2c5Ci770p9VEC08 chris at q957
(ED25519)
>      3072 SHA256:dJws+ny7+uWMo2hwFl6yNGE5vFsW1ZKiO0EXwTIfNPc chris at t470
(RSA)
>      256 SHA256:BxqEiksrCXPxKvQyBXqOqw1WKda110lYiC00Z+fKP4A chris at q957
(ED25519)
>      chris$ ssh-add -D
>      All identities removed.
>      chris$ ssh-add -l
>      256 SHA256:4XDYbepg8zK43pofpQ8IGxMAXkej298a0XZHWjJTIQQ chris at q957
(ED25519)
>      3072 SHA256:yeQw8xe9rrxHKLqICoXNwReZKKV9HI1UeTCf95QywXM chris at t470
(RSA)
>      256 SHA256:dluRgJeTqJ32jKxRrSdjr/cibbIOZQeq8Inlna3+Sdw chris at q957
(ED25519)
>      256 SHA256:gl9l9m/xnYpL9P7WkL60L+FcJ0+r2c5Ci770p9VEC08 chris at q957
(ED25519)
>      3072 SHA256:dJws+ny7+uWMo2hwFl6yNGE5vFsW1ZKiO0EXwTIfNPc chris at t470
(RSA)
>      256 SHA256:BxqEiksrCXPxKvQyBXqOqw1WKda110lYiC00Z+fKP4A chris at q957
(ED25519)
>      chris$
>
> I guess I'm misunderstanding something but I don't see what at the
moment.
Platform? ssh version? What's acting as the ssh-agent?

It works fine for me:

% ssh-add -l
2048 SHA256:mVV81jWVCP/SDRFA7vRM/SDQniylCAcBoSERWyhAXEo 
/Users/brian/.ssh/id_rsa (RSA)
384 SHA256:zUsLa+byMzU+Q3l2HGjfH++SyjdKjr0+imT9jSsEYcY 
vault-6304493e-deploy (ECDSA-CERT)
% ssh-add -D
All identities removed.
% ssh-add -l
The agent has no identities.
%

This is with macOS 14.7, OpenSSH_9.7p1 from homebrew. macOS has started 
a "/usr/bin/ssh-agent -l" process which I believe is from Apple's 
installation of OpenSSH_9.7p1 (according to /usr/bin/ssh -V)

Apparently Analagous Threads

Search for more possibly parallel threads

openssh unix dev - Oct 2024 - Confusion using "ssh-add -D" and then "ssh-add -l"

Confusion using "ssh-add -D" and then "ssh-add -l"

Confusion using "ssh-add -D" and then "ssh-add -l"

Confusion using "ssh-add -D" and then "ssh-add -l"

Apparently Analagous Threads