Lustre discuss - Aug 2011 - inconsistent client behavior when creating an empty directory

Hi,

the following code does not work as expected:
---------
#include <sys/stat.h>
#include <errno.h>
#include <stdio.h>

int main(int argc, char** argv) {

  int rc;
  rc=mkdir(argv[1],S_IRWXU);
  if(rc) perror("failed create dir");
  chown(argv[1],4103,4100);

  struct stat buf;
  /* stat(argv[1],&buf); */

  setresuid(0,4103,4100);
  rc=mkdir(argv[1],S_IRWXU);
  if(rc) perror("failed create dir as user");
}
---------

initial status:

# ls -ld /lustre/test
drwxr-xr-x 2 root root 4096 Aug  9 14:59 /lustre/test
# ls -l /lustre/test
total 0

1) running the test program:

# /tmp/test /lustre/test/testdir
failed create dir as user: Permission denied
# ls -l /lustre/test
total 4
drwx------ 2 griduser03 grid 4096 Aug  9 15:02 testdir

griduser03, grid correspond to uid=4103,gid=4100


2) running the test program, but with uncommented stat call:
# /tmp/test /lustre/test/testdir
failed create dir as user: File exists
# ls -l /lustre/test
total 4
drwx------ 2 griduser03 grid 4096 Aug  9 15:04 testdir


The code first makes the testdir as root and changes the ownership to uid 4103. 
Then it tries to (re)create the same dir with the user privileges. 

If "stat" is called, the code behaves as expected (case 2), but if not
(case
1), the second mkdir should return EEXIST and not EACCES. Is this behavior 
expected or is it a client bug? The client runs lustre 1.8.6.

The code just illustrates, what is actually used in a complex software.

Andrej

-- 
_____________________________________________________________
   prof. dr. Andrej Filipcic,   E-mail: Andrej.Filipcic at ijs.si
   Department of Experimental High Energy Physics - F9
   Jozef Stefan Institute, Jamova 39, P.o.Box 3000
   SI-1001 Ljubljana, Slovenia
   Tel.: +386-1-477-3674    Fax: +386-1-477-3166
-------------------------------------------------------------

This appears to be the same issue as 
https://bugzilla.lustre.org/show_bug.cgi?id=23459

Kevin


Andrej Filipcic wrote:
> Hi,
>
> the following code does not work as expected:
> ---------
> #include <sys/stat.h>
> #include <errno.h>
> #include <stdio.h>
>
> int main(int argc, char** argv) {
>
>   int rc;
>   rc=mkdir(argv[1],S_IRWXU);
>   if(rc) perror("failed create dir");
>   chown(argv[1],4103,4100);
>
>   struct stat buf;
>   /* stat(argv[1],&buf); */
>
>   setresuid(0,4103,4100);
>   rc=mkdir(argv[1],S_IRWXU);
>   if(rc) perror("failed create dir as user");
> }
> ---------
>
> initial status:
>
> # ls -ld /lustre/test
> drwxr-xr-x 2 root root 4096 Aug  9 14:59 /lustre/test
> # ls -l /lustre/test
> total 0
>
> 1) running the test program:
>
> # /tmp/test /lustre/test/testdir
> failed create dir as user: Permission denied
> # ls -l /lustre/test
> total 4
> drwx------ 2 griduser03 grid 4096 Aug  9 15:02 testdir
>
> griduser03, grid correspond to uid=4103,gid=4100
>
>
> 2) running the test program, but with uncommented stat call:
> # /tmp/test /lustre/test/testdir
> failed create dir as user: File exists
> # ls -l /lustre/test
> total 4
> drwx------ 2 griduser03 grid 4096 Aug  9 15:04 testdir
>
>
> The code first makes the testdir as root and changes the ownership to uid
4103.
> Then it tries to (re)create the same dir with the user privileges. 
>
> If "stat" is called, the code behaves as expected (case 2), but
if not (case
> 1), the second mkdir should return EEXIST and not EACCES. Is this behavior 
> expected or is it a client bug? The client runs lustre 1.8.6.
>
> The code just illustrates, what is actually used in a complex software.
>
> Andrej
>
>