llvm dev - Oct 2019 - How to express a dependency to, e.g., DCE-pass?

Hi list,

We wrote a custom transform-pass which transforms code at IR-level.

We would like to have it be executed by the pass-manager ideally at the
"very end" of all optimization passed. After constant-propagation and
dead-code-elimination (and maybe others).

However, we're unable to achieve that for the moment. What is the right
way to express a dependency or to position the pass?

We added INITIALIZE_PASS_DEPENDENCY(ADCELegacyPass) and it seems we
need to add something to getAnalysis<>() but everything we tried
didn't
compile.

Furthermore we saw that, when running clang with -mllvm
-debug-pass=Structure that there seems to be several optimizations
"stages". Our passes are always in the first "stage" whereas
the
DCE-passes are running in a later stage.

Where is our mistake? It seems we are missing some basic knowledge
about the PassManager. 

Thanks in advance for any help.

best regards,
--
Patrick.

On Thu, 10 Oct 2019 15:21:16 +0200
Patrick Boettcher via llvm-dev <llvm-dev at lists.llvm.org> wrote:
> Hi list,
> 
> We wrote a custom transform-pass which transforms code at IR-level.
> 
> We would like to have it be executed by the pass-manager ideally at
> the "very end" of all optimization passed. After
constant-propagation
> and dead-code-elimination (and maybe others).
> 
> However, we're unable to achieve that for the moment. What is the
> right way to express a dependency or to position the pass?
> 
> We added INITIALIZE_PASS_DEPENDENCY(ADCELegacyPass) and it seems we
> need to add something to getAnalysis<>() but everything we tried
> didn't compile.
> 
> Furthermore we saw that, when running clang with -mllvm
> -debug-pass=Structure that there seems to be several optimizations
> "stages". Our passes are always in the first "stage"
whereas the
> DCE-passes are running in a later stage.
> 
> Where is our mistake? It seems we are missing some basic knowledge
> about the PassManager. 
Found a solution fixing our problem. We added the pass to the
Pass-Manager (within BackendUtil.cpp) in Clang. Now we moved it to IPC
in llvm and there all Passes are available to express dependencies.

--
Patrick.