llvm dev - Jun 2010 - [LLVMdev] Proposal for adding rounding variant of fpto?i instructions

Hi,

I would appreciate comments/feedback on this proposal to extend the
fpto?i instructions to support rounding.   This is my first proposed
significant extension to LLVM so I'd like to know if I'm completely
off base here.

First of all, I noticed the convert* intrinsics corresponding to the
CONVERT_RNDSAT InstructionDAG.  I propose not to build my work on
top of these as they seem to be temporary.  Dan Gohman on IRC let me
know these are used by a closed source OpenCL backend, and I imagine
that at some stage the OpenCL backend could migrate to the standard
conversion instructions.

This is what I propose:

Add a "round" flag to FPToUIInst and FPToSIInst.  The absence of this
flag means truncation is needed whereas presence indicates rounding.

The SelectionDAG for FP_TO_UINT and FP_TO_SINT are extended to add
an immediate that indicates whether rounding is needed.

To legalise a rounding FP_TO_UINT or FP_TO_SINT we use the technique
described in [1] to convert the operation into an add/bitcast.

Please let me know what you think.

Thanks,
-- 
Peter

[1] http://www.d6.com/users/checker/pdfs/gdmfp.pdf