The if_wpi driver is all kinds of broken. The reported problems really just are the tip of the iceberg: http://www.freebsd.org/cgi/query-pr.cgi?pr=144898 A notebook without wireless is really just a portable workstation. I've seen a lot of commits to other wireless drivers in recent months. So it's not like nobody's working on this kind of stuff. Because no amount of persuasion and detailed bug reports help and I have no clue what the error codes returned by the firmware blob imply (documentation anywhere?), I think I have to ask the one question: Where do I have to put my cash to make somebody fix this?
On 01/-10/63 19:59, Dominic Fandrey wrote:> The if_wpi driver is all kinds of broken. The reported problemsI have had trouble with all Intel drivers, ipw, iwi, wpi, and iwn. (As an exception, recently, iwn was very stable on 8-STABLE.) For most notebooks, I bought Atheros based MiniPCI(e) cards and everything was fine.> Where do I have to put my cash to make somebody fix this?5 to 10 Euros on Ebay including shipping. Initially, I was hesitant, too, because I wanted the hardware I already got to work, but eventually I decided that it is not worse it. ath simply works. (I have had wi, ral, ural, rum, and zyd, too. Over the years, nothing was as unproblematic as ath.) For most notebooks, the wireless MiniPCI(e) card is very easy to replace. Cheers, Jan Henrik
On Mon, May 17, 2010 at 4:01 PM, Jan Henrik Sylvester <me@janh.de> wrote:> On 01/-10/63 19:59, Dominic Fandrey wrote: >> >> The if_wpi driver is all kinds of broken. The reported problems > > I have had trouble with all Intel drivers, ipw, iwi, wpi, and iwn. (As an > exception, recently, iwn was very stable on 8-STABLE.) For most notebooks, I > bought Atheros based MiniPCI(e) cards and everything was fine. > >> Where do I have to put my cash to make somebody fix this? > > 5 to 10 Euros on Ebay including shipping. Initially, I was hesitant, too, > because I wanted the hardware I already got to work, but eventually I > decided that it is not worse it. ath simply works. (I have had wi, ral, > ural, rum, and zyd, too. Over the years, nothing was as unproblematic as > ath.) > > For most notebooks, the wireless MiniPCI(e) card is very easy to replace. > > Cheers, > Jan HenrikNote that not all laptops will play nicely with different wifi cards. My old HP laptop would not boot up past the BIOS if you replaced the wifi card with one not in its magic list, which I found out after I had bought an ath based mini pci-e card to replace it (which is still spare if anyone wants it). Cheers Tom