freebsd stable - Aug 2004 - How to successfully mount /root if not in fstab?

Hi,

I've been caught out (twice now - yes, I was stupid enough to do this
twice!) with mounting /root after removing a hard disk from my system and
would like to know why it wasn't trivial to recover. I had FreeBSD 4.10
installed on ad1, with ad0 hosting the boot manager and ad1 containing an
msdos boot sector; I removed ad0 from the system and forgot to edit
/etc/fstab before rebooting. With ad1 now ad0, the system booted the kernel
ok, but /root couldn't be found (of course) - at this point all was as
expected. However, when prompted for a mount command, I don't know why
"ufs:/dev/ad0s1a" didn't work - error 6 and the prompt was
redisplayed.

To recover, I booted from a fixit CD, mounted /root and edited fstab to
reflect the new arrangement and all was well. However, I discovered another
anomaly while doing this - when I entered the fixit shell I first tried
"fsck -y /dev/ad0s1a" but it returned an error about /etc/fstab. I was
able to "mount -o rw /dev/ad0s1a /mydir", however. Why?

Sorry for the lack of detail, but I'll bet both of these things have been
encountered by many others before...

cheers,
-- Joel Hatton --
Security Analyst                    | Hotline: +61 7 3365 4417
AusCERT - Australia's national CERT | Fax:     +61 7 3365 7031
The University of Queensland        | WWW:     www.auscert.org.au
Qld 4072 Australia                  | Email:   auscert@auscert.org.au

On Aug 2, 2004, at 2:49 AM, Joel Hatton wrote:
> I've been caught out (twice now - yes, I was stupid enough to do this
> twice!) with mounting /root after removing a hard disk from my system 
> and
> would like to know why it wasn't trivial to recover.
The system requires a working root account in order to be repairable in 
single-user mode.  One consequence of this is that /root needs to be on 
the same partition as /, for much the same reasons that /bin or /etc 
needs to be on /.

-- 
-Chuck