Hello,
I have what I would think would be a common situation: I run asterisk at
home simply as a land line. I started a new job working remotely and
they gave me a SIP account with user name, domain, and proxy. I've never
had to deal with sip domains before. My user '140 at 4354766787.com' is
handled by a 3rd party provider: 'sip.provider.com' and my local domain
on my asterisk box is the hostname 'mypbxdomain.com'.
My normal extension I use for everything is just '111'. I figured the
best way of joining my asterisk box was to just hard code in the
extensions I would need to dial for my remote office work (there are
only a couple of extensions so shouldn't be a big deal).
However I struggled to get authentication working for outgoing calls to
the few new extensions at the remote office through their provider.
Looking at debug logs it was clear that the sip 'To' address was wrong.
It had the provider: "To: <sip:139 at sip.provider.com>" instead
of the
domain which should look like: "To: <sip:139 at 4354766787.com>"
(right?)
In the end, after hours of googling, reading the docs on sip.conf
several times revealed a little spoke of '!' dialplan option. Simply
changing my dialplan from 'Dial(SIP/workphone/${EXTEN})' to
'Dial(SIP/workphone/${EXTEN}!${EXTEN}@4354766787.com)' fixed the issue.
But this seems really hackish. Is this the right/only way? Or is just
having a provider and mismatched domains not really the norm?
I have an an anonymized log here: http://tinyurl.com/ouy2ajr
Regards,
Sam
On 08/21/2015 12:52 AM, Sam wrote:> Hello, > > I have what I would think would be a common situation: I run asterisk at > home simply as a land line. I started a new job working remotely and > they gave me a SIP account with user name, domain, and proxy. I've never > had to deal with sip domains before. My user '140 at 4354766787.com' is > handled by a 3rd party provider: 'sip.provider.com' and my local domain > on my asterisk box is the hostname 'mypbxdomain.com'. > > My normal extension I use for everything is just '111'. I figured the > best way of joining my asterisk box was to just hard code in the > extensions I would need to dial for my remote office work (there are > only a couple of extensions so shouldn't be a big deal). > > However I struggled to get authentication working for outgoing calls to > the few new extensions at the remote office through their provider. > Looking at debug logs it was clear that the sip 'To' address was wrong. > It had the provider: "To: <sip:139 at sip.provider.com>" instead of the > domain which should look like: "To: <sip:139 at 4354766787.com>" (right?) > > In the end, after hours of googling, reading the docs on sip.conf > several times revealed a little spoke of '!' dialplan option. Simply > changing my dialplan from 'Dial(SIP/workphone/${EXTEN})' to > 'Dial(SIP/workphone/${EXTEN}!${EXTEN}@4354766787.com)' fixed the issue. > > But this seems really hackish. Is this the right/only way? Or is just > having a provider and mismatched domains not really the norm? > > I have an an anonymized log here: http://tinyurl.com/ouy2ajr > > > > Regards, > Sam >So since no one has responded, this either means one of two things: Either I am an idiot and missed something obvious and therefore no one wants to deal with me. Or this is indeed not something typical of an asterisk config. Can someone at least point me to which? :) As I mentioned, everything is working, it just doesn't "feel" right. Regards, Sam
royj at yandex.ru
2015-Aug-24 07:58 UTC
[asterisk-users] SIP domain different than provider's
I think you chose the right solution in your case. It might doesn't "feel" right if you corrected source code, I think. 23.08.2015, 20:53, "Sam" <asterisk at net153.net>:> On 08/21/2015 12:52 AM, Sam wrote: >> ?Hello, >> >> ?I have what I would think would be a common situation: I run asterisk at >> ?home simply as a land line. I started a new job working remotely and >> ?they gave me a SIP account with user name, domain, and proxy. I've never >> ?had to deal with sip domains before. My user '140 at 4354766787.com' is >> ?handled by a 3rd party provider: 'sip.provider.com' and my local domain >> ?on my asterisk box is the hostname 'mypbxdomain.com'. >> >> ?My normal extension I use for everything is just '111'. I figured the >> ?best way of joining my asterisk box was to just hard code in the >> ?extensions I would need to dial for my remote office work (there are >> ?only a couple of extensions so shouldn't be a big deal). >> >> ?However I struggled to get authentication working for outgoing calls to >> ?the few new extensions at the remote office through their provider. >> ?Looking at debug logs it was clear that the sip 'To' address was wrong. >> ?It had the provider: "To: <sip:139 at sip.provider.com>" instead of the >> ?domain which should look like: "To: <sip:139 at 4354766787.com>" (right?) >> >> ?In the end, after hours of googling, reading the docs on sip.conf >> ?several times revealed a little spoke of '!' dialplan option. Simply >> ?changing my dialplan from 'Dial(SIP/workphone/${EXTEN})' to >> ?'Dial(SIP/workphone/${EXTEN}!${EXTEN}@4354766787.com)' fixed the issue. >> >> ?But this seems really hackish. Is this the right/only way? Or is just >> ?having a provider and mismatched domains not really the norm? >> >> ?I have an an anonymized log here: http://tinyurl.com/ouy2ajr >> >> ?Regards, >> ?Sam > > So since no one has responded, this either means one of two things: > Either I am an idiot and missed something obvious and therefore no one > wants to deal with me. Or this is indeed not something typical of an > asterisk config. > > Can someone at least point me to which? :) > As I mentioned, everything is working, it just doesn't "feel" right. > > Regards, > Sam > > -- > _____________________________________________________________________ > -- Bandwidth and Colocation Provided by http://www.api-digital.com -- > New to Asterisk? Join us for a live introductory webinar every Thurs: > ???????????????http://www.asterisk.org/hello > > asterisk-users mailing list > To UNSUBSCRIBE or update options visit: > ???http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users