asterisk users - Oct 2008 - Asterisk 1.6.0 CDR billsec and duration not working from h extension

Can someone tell me what I am doing wrong?  Why doesn't CDR(duration)  
or CDR(billsec) return the correct values?

cdr.conf

endbeforehexten=yes


extensions.conf

[macro-Dial]
; ${ARG1} - Dial String

exten => s,1,Dial(${ARG1},,M(post-dial))

exten => h,1,NoOp(Call was hung up - ${CDR(duration)} seconds long,  
billed for ${CDR(billsec)} seconds)


The log shows:

     -- Executing [h at macro-Dial:1]
NoOp("SIP/10.10.10.170-b7d94f78",
"Call was hung up - 0 seconds long, billed for 0 seconds") in new
stack


But cdr-csv/Master.csv has logged time values for duration and billsec:

"","5105550000","+4155550001","pop-inbound","""15105550000""
<5105550000>","SIP/10.10.10.170-b7d94f78","SIP/ 
voipprovider.com-089ae8a0","Dial","SIP/15105550000:password::authname
at voipprovider.com
,,M(post-dial)","2008-10-09 20:59:00","2008-10-09  
20:59:03","2008-10-09 20:59:08", 
8,5,"ANSWERED","DOCUMENTATION","1223585940.35"


--
Eric Chamberlain

Eric Chamberlain wrote:
> Can someone tell me what I am doing wrong?  Why doesn't CDR(duration)  
> or CDR(billsec) return the correct values?
> 
> cdr.conf
> 
> endbeforehexten=yes
> 
> 
> extensions.conf
> 
> [macro-Dial]
> ; ${ARG1} - Dial String
> 
> exten => s,1,Dial(${ARG1},,M(post-dial))
> 
> exten => h,1,NoOp(Call was hung up - ${CDR(duration)} seconds long,  
> billed for ${CDR(billsec)} seconds)
> 
> 
> The log shows:
> 
>      -- Executing [h at macro-Dial:1]
NoOp("SIP/10.10.10.170-b7d94f78",
> "Call was hung up - 0 seconds long, billed for 0 seconds") in new
stack
> 
> 
> But cdr-csv/Master.csv has logged time values for duration and billsec:
> 
>
"","5105550000","+4155550001","pop-inbound","""15105550000""
> <5105550000>","SIP/10.10.10.170-b7d94f78","SIP/ 
>
voipprovider.com-089ae8a0","Dial","SIP/15105550000:password::authname
at voipprovider.com
> ,,M(post-dial)","2008-10-09 20:59:00","2008-10-09  
> 20:59:03","2008-10-09 20:59:08", 
>
8,5,"ANSWERED","DOCUMENTATION","1223585940.35"
> 
> 
> --
> Eric Chamberlain
> 
Eric,


Asterisk CDR @logging@ is just no less then short of shite. An absolute 
DEAD end.


WHO ever is in charge of Digium is not doing its JOB.



Senad
www.bicomsystems.com

(Morao sam da im kazem  :) )

On Thu, 2008-10-09 at 14:09 -0700, Eric Chamberlain
wrote:
> Can someone tell me what I am doing wrong?  Why doesn't CDR(duration)  
> or CDR(billsec) return the correct values?
> 
> cdr.conf
> 
> endbeforehexten=yes
> 
> 
Eric--

To fix a problem, I had to reshuffle things around in the
asterisk core; one involves posting the CDR just after a bridge
ends; and therefore, before the hangup exten is run. To fix this,
I inserted a loop to run the hangup exten just after the 
bridge ends; This all introduced a crash and some hopefully
short-lived problems with asterisk while we find and work out the
kinks.

I believe that Russell has held back the fixes from 1.6.0 until
the dust settles. But in 1.4 svn, the new code is in place;
I do have a crash bug report filed against it, and am waiting for
the reporter to give enough info to debug it, but I get positive
reports from most.

So, my advice is to back up to a version where the h exten works with
CDR calls;
and then skip forward when the fixes are included. You'll have to suffer
with the bugs that prompted the fixes, but if you haven't noticed them
before, you might not for a while longer.

Sorry to disturb the user community wrt to CDR's, but the bugs are
tough to kill and getting one usually has unintended, negative
side-affects. If
I knew of a better way, I'd be doing it that way... gee, I thought I 
was doing it the "better way"!

The current fixes did go to patch on bug reports, and the user community
is always invited to test these out and report. If no-one does that,
then
we stick it in and folks get problems... sorry!

murf

> extensions.conf
> 
> [macro-Dial]
> ; ${ARG1} - Dial String
> 
> exten => s,1,Dial(${ARG1},,M(post-dial))
> 
> exten => h,1,NoOp(Call was hung up - ${CDR(duration)} seconds long,  
> billed for ${CDR(billsec)} seconds)
> 
> 
> The log shows:
> 
>      -- Executing [h at macro-Dial:1]
NoOp("SIP/10.10.10.170-b7d94f78",
> "Call was hung up - 0 seconds long, billed for 0 seconds") in new
stack
> 
> 
> But cdr-csv/Master.csv has logged time values for duration and billsec:
> 
>
"","5105550000","+4155550001","pop-inbound","""15105550000""
> <5105550000>","SIP/10.10.10.170-b7d94f78","SIP/ 
>
voipprovider.com-089ae8a0","Dial","SIP/15105550000:password::authname
at voipprovider.com
> ,,M(post-dial)","2008-10-09 20:59:00","2008-10-09  
> 20:59:03","2008-10-09 20:59:08", 
>
8,5,"ANSWERED","DOCUMENTATION","1223585940.35"
> 
> 
> --
> Eric Chamberlain
-- 
Steve Murphy
Software Developer
Digium
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: smime.p7s
Type: application/x-pkcs7-signature
Size: 3227 bytes
Desc: not available
Url :
http://lists.digium.com/pipermail/asterisk-users/attachments/20081009/5eb91e73/attachment.bin