samba - Nov 2020 - changes on DC not replicated, while showrepl reports no issues

On 17/11/2020 11:54, mj via samba wrote:
> Hi,
>
> Checking a bit more today, as the two changes on DC4 have *still* not 
> propagated? to DC2/DC3, I discovered the
> ?samba-tool drs uptodateness
> command.
>
> I gives the following output, not sure what "unknown invocation
ID"
> means. I hope someone here is able to explain..?
>
> It's output:
>
>> root at dc2:~# samba-tool drs uptodateness
>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>> DOMAIN????????? maximum: 1? median: 0.0? failure: 0
>> CONFIGURATION?? maximum: 1? median: 1.0? failure: 0
>> SCHEMA????????? maximum: 1? median: 1.0? failure: 0
>> DNSDOMAIN?????? maximum: 1? median: 1.0? failure: 0
>> DNSFOREST?????? maximum: 1? median: 1.0? failure: 0
>
> Any idea what this means?
>
> On DC3, it lists the same Unknown invocation ID, but ends differently:
>> DOMAIN????????? maximum: 0? median: 0.0 failure: 0
>> CONFIGURATION?? maximum: 0? median: 0.0? failure: 0
>> SCHEMA????????? maximum: 0? median: 0.0? failure: 0
>> DNSDOMAIN?????? maximum: 0? median: 0.0? failure: 0
>> DNSFOREST?????? maximum: 0? median: 0.0? failure: 0
>
> Output on DC4 (the one where we made the change yesterday) looks like 
> DC3 above.
>
> Not sure what this means.
>
> And worried that this samba-tool drs showrepl still shows nothing 
> wrong at all, though there clearly IS an issue.
>
> Warning to everyone: use the samba-tool ldapcmp command to verify LDAP 
> contents between your DCs! Don't just trust your showrepl output..!
>
> MJ
>
Try reading this:

http://www.frickelsoft.net/blog/?p=148

Rowland

Hi Rowland,

On 11/17/20 1:11 PM, Rowland penny via samba wrote:
> Try reading this:
> 
> http://www.frickelsoft.net/blog/?p=148
I googled for "unknown invocation id" and samba, and found nothing
much.

Thanks for the article now, I read it. (plus some more)

They seem to be on AD DC restores etc. But the thing is: we know not to 
restore a DC (and instead add new DCs), and therefore never restored one.

This AD has been running stable for a number of years now.

At one point, years ago, we had issues, and decided to continue with one 
of our DCs (I think it was DC2). We removed the others, re-added them, 
and ever since, there have been no issues.

We run hourly ldapcmp, and showrpel etc, so I'm pretty sure that things 
have been in sync for some years now, and through many samba updates.

Are the "unknown invocation IDs" the base of our issue?

Could that explain why samba-tool visualize reps says that "there is no 
connection" for DOMAIN from DC4 to DC3/DC2?

Insights on how to proceed..? We've stopped making changes on our AD for 
now.

MJ

On 17/11/2020 12:41, mj via samba wrote:
> Hi Rowland,
>
> On 11/17/20 1:11 PM, Rowland penny via samba wrote:
>> Try reading this:
>>
>> http://www.frickelsoft.net/blog/?p=148
>
> I googled for "unknown invocation id" and samba, and found
nothing much.
>
> Thanks for the article now, I read it. (plus some more)
>
> They seem to be on AD DC restores etc. But the thing is: we know not 
> to restore a DC (and instead add new DCs), and therefore never 
> restored one.
>
> This AD has been running stable for a number of years now.
>
> At one point, years ago, we had issues, and decided to continue with 
> one of our DCs (I think it was DC2). We removed the others, re-added 
> them, and ever since, there have been no issues.
>
> We run hourly ldapcmp, and showrpel etc, so I'm pretty sure that 
> things have been in sync for some years now, and through many samba 
> updates.
>
> Are the "unknown invocation IDs" the base of our issue?
>
> Could that explain why samba-tool visualize reps says that "there is 
> no connection" for DOMAIN from DC4 to DC3/DC2?
>
> Insights on how to proceed..? We've stopped making changes on our AD 
> for now.
>
> MJ
>
I was unsure whether you had restored the DC, but the outcome is the 
same, if you have one DC that isn't working correctly and all the others 
are, then demote the faulty DC and join a new one in its place.

What you must never do (and I think you understand this) is to to 
restore an individual DC from a backup, only use a backup to restore an 
entire domain.

Rowland

Am 17.11.20 um 13:11 schrieb Rowland penny via samba:
>> It's output:
>>
>>> root at dc2:~# samba-tool drs uptodateness
>>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
>>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
>>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
>>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
>>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
>>> DOMAIN????????? maximum: 1? median: 0.0? failure: 0
>>> CONFIGURATION?? maximum: 1? median: 1.0? failure: 0
>>> SCHEMA????????? maximum: 1? median: 1.0? failure: 0
>>> DNSDOMAIN?????? maximum: 1? median: 1.0? failure: 0
>>> DNSFOREST?????? maximum: 1? median: 1.0? failure: 0
>>
>> Any idea what this means?

This would interests me also. For us the output looks more or less the 
same. What do others have when they run this command?

Regards

Christian

-- 
Dr. Christian Naumer
Unit Head Bioprocess Development

B.R.A.I.N Aktiengesellschaft
Darmstaedter Str. 34-36, D-64673 Zwingenberg
e-mail cn at brain-biotech.com, homepage www.brain-biotech.com
fon +49-6251-9331-30  /   fax +49-6251-9331-11

Subscribe to BRAIN's Newsletter:
http://www.brain-biotech.com/de/newsletter

Sitz der Gesellschaft: Zwingenberg/Bergstrasse
Registergericht AG Darmstadt, HRB 24758
Vorstand: Adriaan Moelker (Vorstandsvorsitzender), 
Lukas Linnig
Aufsichtsratsvorsitzender: Dr. Georg Kellinghusen

Same as MJ and You. 

So you have 5 DC's running. 
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
> >>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
> >>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
> >>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
> >>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
> >>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
> >>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
I see the same. 

Only with one difference.  
Now you would think now i have 2 DC's running in you see this. But i have 3
DC's running.
One is missing and i bet its the samba 4.13.2. (recently installed). 
And the 2 other servers originated from a samba 4.1.x 
Unknown invocation ID 00a544f5-964f-4348-9fa1-ae2b3ee4e08a
Unknown invocation ID 7e4659b4-c78f-45a3-be02-9881e17b2cc8
Unknown invocation ID 00a544f5-964f-4348-9fa1-ae2b3ee4e08a
Unknown invocation ID 7e4659b4-c78f-45a3-be02-9881e17b2cc8
Unknown invocation ID 00a544f5-964f-4348-9fa1-ae2b3ee4e08a
Unknown invocation ID 7e4659b4-c78f-45a3-be02-9881e17b2cc8
Unknown invocation ID 00a544f5-964f-4348-9fa1-ae2b3ee4e08a
Unknown invocation ID 7e4659b4-c78f-45a3-be02-9881e17b2cc8
Unknown invocation ID 00a544f5-964f-4348-9fa1-ae2b3ee4e08a
Unknown invocation ID 7e4659b4-c78f-45a3-be02-9881e17b2cc8
Unknown invocation ID 00a544f5-964f-4348-9fa1-ae2b3ee4e08a
Unknown invocation ID 7e4659b4-c78f-45a3-be02-9881e17b2cc8
Unknown invocation ID 00a544f5-964f-4348-9fa1-ae2b3ee4e08a
Unknown invocation ID 7e4659b4-c78f-45a3-be02-9881e17b2cc8
Unknown invocation ID 00a544f5-964f-4348-9fa1-ae2b3ee4e08a
Unknown invocation ID 7e4659b4-c78f-45a3-be02-9881e17b2cc8
Unknown invocation ID 00a544f5-964f-4348-9fa1-ae2b3ee4e08a
Unknown invocation ID 7e4659b4-c78f-45a3-be02-9881e17b2cc8
Unknown invocation ID 00a544f5-964f-4348-9fa1-ae2b3ee4e08a
Unknown invocation ID 7e4659b4-c78f-45a3-be02-9881e17b2cc8
Unknown invocation ID 00a544f5-964f-4348-9fa1-ae2b3ee4e08a
Unknown invocation ID 7e4659b4-c78f-45a3-be02-9881e17b2cc8
Unknown invocation ID 00a544f5-964f-4348-9fa1-ae2b3ee4e08a
Unknown invocation ID 7e4659b4-c78f-45a3-be02-9881e17b2cc8
Unknown invocation ID 00a544f5-964f-4348-9fa1-ae2b3ee4e08a
Unknown invocation ID 7e4659b4-c78f-45a3-be02-9881e17b2cc8
Unknown invocation ID 00a544f5-964f-4348-9fa1-ae2b3ee4e08a
Unknown invocation ID 7e4659b4-c78f-45a3-be02-9881e17b2cc8
Unknown invocation ID 00a544f5-964f-4348-9fa1-ae2b3ee4e08a
Unknown invocation ID 7e4659b4-c78f-45a3-be02-9881e17b2cc8
DOMAIN          maximum: 0  median: 0.0  failure: 0
CONFIGURATION   maximum: 0  median: 0.0  failure: 0
SCHEMA          maximum: 0  median: 0.0  failure: 0
DNSDOMAIN       maximum: 0  median: 0.0  failure: 0
DNSFOREST       maximum: 0  median: 0.0  failure: 0


I also see here 0. for all value for me and for MJ and You i noticed these.
>>> DOMAIN????????? maximum: 1? median: 0.0? failure: 0
>>> CONFIGURATION?? maximum: 1? median: 1.0? failure: 0
>>> SCHEMA????????? maximum: 1? median: 1.0? failure: 0
>>> DNSDOMAIN?????? maximum: 1? median: 1.0? failure: 0
>>> DNSFOREST?????? maximum: 1? median: 1.0? failure: 0
I could only find myself.
https://lists.samba.org/archive/samba/2019-November/226912.html 

;-) 
samba-tool visualize uptodateness -r
Does not show out of sync here. 

Rowland, you any ideas on that. 
This might be just cosmetic. 

Greetz.

Louis


> -----Oorspronkelijk bericht-----
> Van: samba [mailto:samba-bounces at lists.samba.org] Namens 
> cn--- via samba
> Verzonden: dinsdag 17 november 2020 14:11
> >> It's output:
> >>
> >>> root at dc2:~# samba-tool drs uptodateness
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
> >>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
> >>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
> >>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
> >>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
> >>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
> >>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
> >>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
> >>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
> >>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
> >>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
> >>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
> >>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
> >>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
> >>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
> >>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
> >>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
> >>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
> >>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
> >>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
> >>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
> >>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
> >>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
> >>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
> >>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
> >>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
> >>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
> >>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
> >>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 556b2cb4-e576-48e2-bb7c-7f62caee84fc
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 7281ff0f-5af2-4ded-bdaf-362f1545d221
> >>> Unknown invocation ID 82b24c02-16cb-4ed1-b68b-a047c26886a9
> >>> Unknown invocation ID b97cc603-6d03-4ad0-8629-be408fed8d69
> >>> Unknown invocation ID e50c4440-f3d2-429e-a19d-c11bc72f5565
> >>> DOMAIN????????? maximum: 1? median: 0.0? failure: 0
> >>> CONFIGURATION?? maximum: 1? median: 1.0? failure: 0
> >>> SCHEMA????????? maximum: 1? median: 1.0? failure: 0
> >>> DNSDOMAIN?????? maximum: 1? median: 1.0? failure: 0
> >>> DNSFOREST?????? maximum: 1? median: 1.0? failure: 0
> >>
> >> Any idea what this means?
> 
> 
> This would interests me also. For us the output looks more or 
> less the 
> same. What do others have when they run this command?
> 
> Regards
> 
> Christian
> 
> -- 
> Dr. Christian Naumer
> Unit Head Bioprocess Development
> 
> B.R.A.I.N Aktiengesellschaft
> Darmstaedter Str. 34-36, D-64673 Zwingenberg
> e-mail cn at brain-biotech.com, homepage www.brain-biotech.com
> fon +49-6251-9331-30  /   fax +49-6251-9331-11
> 
> Subscribe to BRAIN's Newsletter:
> http://www.brain-biotech.com/de/newsletter
> 
> Sitz der Gesellschaft: Zwingenberg/Bergstrasse
> Registergericht AG Darmstadt, HRB 24758
> Vorstand: Adriaan Moelker (Vorstandsvorsitzender), 
> Lukas Linnig
> Aufsichtsratsvorsitzender: Dr. Georg Kellinghusen
> 
> -- 
> To unsubscribe from this list go to the following URL and read the
> instructions:  https://lists.samba.org/mailman/options/samba
> 
>

Am 17.11.20 um 15:40 schrieb L.P.H. van Belle via samba:
> DOMAIN          maximum: 0  median: 0.0  failure: 0
> CONFIGURATION   maximum: 0  median: 0.0  failure: 0
> SCHEMA          maximum: 0  median: 0.0  failure: 0
> DNSDOMAIN       maximum: 0  median: 0.0  failure: 0
> DNSFOREST       maximum: 0  median: 0.0  failure: 0
> 
> 
> I also see here 0. for all value for me and for MJ and You i noticed these.

I see this here:

DOMAIN          maximum: 44  median: 14.0  failure: 0
CONFIGURATION   maximum: 89  median: 9.0  failure: 0
SCHEMA          maximum: 210  median: 44.5  failure: 0
DNSDOMAIN       maximum: 2  median: 0.0  failure: 0
DNSFOREST       maximum: 90  median: 9.0  failure: 0

Much higher numbers. Is this something to worry?

Regards

Christian

-- 
Dr. Christian Naumer
Unit Head Bioprocess Development

B.R.A.I.N Aktiengesellschaft
Darmstaedter Str. 34-36, D-64673 Zwingenberg
e-mail cn at brain-biotech.com, homepage www.brain-biotech.com
fon +49-6251-9331-30  /   fax +49-6251-9331-11

Subscribe to BRAIN's Newsletter:
http://www.brain-biotech.com/de/newsletter

Sitz der Gesellschaft: Zwingenberg/Bergstrasse
Registergericht AG Darmstadt, HRB 24758
Vorstand: Adriaan Moelker (Vorstandsvorsitzender), 
Lukas Linnig
Aufsichtsratsvorsitzender: Dr. Georg Kellinghusen

Hi Louis,

Never noticed there are only five different unknown invocation IDs, they 
just repaet. :-)

We have only three DCs now, but:

We used to have three, of which we (years ago) ditched two, keeping one 
and added two new ones. So totally in our AD ever has known 5 DCs at 
different times.
> I could only find myself.
> https://lists.samba.org/archive/samba/2019-November/226912.html
Yep I already read that post as well. :-)
> samba-tool visualize uptodateness -r
> Does not show out of sync here.
Same here! No out of syncs there. (it does show "unknown invocation
ID"
in it's output)

MJ

On 17/11/2020 14:40, L.P.H. van Belle via samba wrote:
> samba-tool visualize uptodateness -r
> Does not show out of sync here.
>
> Rowland, you any ideas on that.
> This might be just cosmetic.
It appears it is just cosmetic, see my other post.

I have asked the person who added it, why he added it, I don't expect a 
quick reply, he is on the other side of the planet ?

Rowland