samba - Aug 2020 - Error compiling samba server in MacOS

Hi everyone,

I'm trying to compile samba from macOS Catalina from several days ago 
without success, I'm a newbie on this kind of stuff over mac, so... It 
will probably be a noob error, but I'm lost.

I tried to follow these couple of links, also without success: 
https://medium.com/@mattmatic/compiling-samba-4-on-mac-os-x-high-sierra-24ca6a93a51c
and https://willhaley.com/blog/compile-samba-macos/

The error trace that I always obtain looks as follows:

sudo make -k
WAF_MAKE=1 python ./buildtools/bin/waf build
Waf: Entering directory `/Users/blorente/Sites/repos/samba/bin'
 ??? Selected embedded Heimdal build

[3204/3434] Linking default/source4/client/smbclient4
clang: warning: argument unused during compilation: '-pie' 
[-Wunused-command-line-argument]
Undefined symbols for architecture x86_64:
 ? "_rl_done", referenced from:
 ????? _smb_readline_done in smbreadline_1.o
ld: symbol(s) not found for architecture x86_64
clang: error: linker command failed with exit code 1 (use -v to see 
invocation)





[3215/3434] Linking default/source3/client/smbclient
clang: warning: argument unused during compilation: '-pie' 
[-Wunused-command-line-argument]
Undefined symbols for architecture x86_64:
 ? "_rl_done", referenced from:
 ????? _smb_readline_done in smbreadline_1.o
ld: symbol(s) not found for architecture x86_64
clang: error: linker command failed with exit code 1 (use -v to see 
invocation)




[3234/3434] Linking default/source4/lib/registry/regshell
clang: warning: argument unused during compilation: '-pie' 
[-Wunused-command-line-argument]
Undefined symbols for architecture x86_64:
 ? "_rl_done", referenced from:
 ????? _smb_readline_done in smbreadline_1.o
ld: symbol(s) not found for architecture x86_64
clang: error: linker command failed with exit code 1 (use -v to see 
invocation)




[3316/3434] Linking default/source3/rpcclient/rpcclient
clang: warning: argument unused during compilation: '-pie' 
[-Wunused-command-line-argument]
Undefined symbols for architecture x86_64:
 ? "_rl_done", referenced from:
 ????? _smb_readline_done in smbreadline_1.o
ld: symbol(s) not found for architecture x86_64
clang: error: linker command failed with exit code 1 (use -v to see 
invocation)




[3381/3434] Linking default/source3/utils/net
clang: warning: argument unused during compilation: '-pie' 
[-Wunused-command-line-argument]
Undefined symbols for architecture x86_64:
 ? "_rl_done", referenced from:
 ????? _smb_readline_done in smbreadline_1.o
ld: symbol(s) not found for architecture x86_64
clang: error: linker command failed with exit code 1 (use -v to see 
invocation)




[3403/3434] Linking default/source3/vfstest
clang: warning: argument unused during compilation: '-pie' 
[-Wunused-command-line-argument]
Undefined symbols for architecture x86_64:
 ? "_rl_done", referenced from:
 ????? _smb_readline_done in smbreadline_1.o
ld: symbol(s) not found for architecture x86_64
clang: error: linker command failed with exit code 1 (use -v to see 
invocation)



[3423/3434] Linking default/source4/torture/smbtorture
clang: warning: argument unused during compilation: '-pie' 
[-Wunused-command-line-argument]
Undefined symbols for architecture x86_64:
 ? "_getgrent_r", referenced from:
 ????? _test_enum_r_group in nss_tests_1.o
 ? "_getpwent_r", referenced from:
 ????? _test_enum_r_passwd in nss_tests_1.o
 ? "_rl_done", referenced from:
 ????? _smb_readline_done in smbreadline_1.o
ld: symbol(s) not found for architecture x86_64
clang: error: linker command failed with exit code 1 (use -v to see 
invocation)
Waf: Leaving directory `/Users/blorente/Sites/repos/samba/bin'
Build failed:
 ?-> task failed (err #1):
 ??? {task: cc_link 
client_1.o,popt_common_4.o,smbreadline_1.o,popt_credentials_5.o,clilsa_2.o 
-> smbclient4}
 ?-> task failed (err #1):
 ??? {task: cc_link 
client_121.o,clitar_121.o,dnsbrowse_121.o,smbreadline_1.o -> smbclient}
 ?-> task failed (err #1):
 ??? {task: cc_link 
regshell_11.o,popt_common_4.o,smbreadline_1.o,popt_credentials_5.o,common_5.o 
-> regshell}
 ?-> task failed (err #1):
 ??? {task: cc_link 
rpcclient_1.o,cmd_lsarpc_1.o,cmd_samr_1.o,cmd_spoolss_1.o,cmd_netlogon_1.o,cmd_srvsvc_1.o,cmd_dfs_1.o,cmd_epmapper_1.o,cmd_dssetup_1.o,cmd_echo_1.o,cmd_shutdown_1.o,cmd_test_1.o,cmd_wkssvc_1.o,cmd_ntsvcs_1.o,cmd_drsuapi_1.o,cmd_eventlog_1.o,cmd_winreg_1.o,cmd_fss_1.o,cmd_clusapi_1.o,cmd_witness_1.o,cmd_iremotewinspool_1.o,init_samr_115.o,ndr_winspool_c_136.o,smbreadline_1.o,ndr_drsuapi_c_129.o,ndr_witness_c_165.o,ndr_dssetup_c_146.o,ndr_clusapi_c_166.o,cli_samr_103.o,ndr_fsrvp_c_164.o,cli_pipe_schannel_112.o
-> rpcclient}
 ?-> task failed (err #1):
 ??? {task: cc_link 
libnet_dssync_84.o,libnet_dssync_passdb_84.o,libnet_dssync_keytab_84.o,ndr_dssetup_c_146.o,idmap_autorid_tdb_23.o,smbreadline_1.o,ndr_drsuapi_c_129.o,passwd_util_1.o,net_42.o,net_ads_42.o,net_help_42.o,net_rap_42.o,net_rpc_42.o,net_rpc_samsync_42.o,net_time_42.o,net_lookup_42.o,net_cache_42.o,net_groupmap_42.o,net_idmap_42.o,net_idmap_check_42.o,interact_42.o,net_status_42.o,net_rpc_printer_42.o,net_rpc_rights_42.o,net_rpc_service_42.o,net_rpc_registry_42.o,net_usershare_42.o,netlookup_42.o,net_sam_42.o,net_rpc_shell_42.o,net_util_42.o,net_rpc_sh_acct_42.o,net_rpc_audit_42.o,net_dns_42.o,net_ads_gpo_42.o,net_conf_42.o,net_conf_util_42.o,net_join_42.o,net_user_42.o,net_group_42.o,net_file_42.o,net_registry_42.o,net_registry_check_42.o,net_dom_42.o,net_share_42.o,net_g_lock_42.o,net_serverid_42.o,net_eventlog_42.o,net_printing_42.o,net_rpc_trust_42.o,net_rpc_conf_42.o,net_afs_42.o,net_notify_42.o,net_tdb_42.o,reg_parse_42.o,reg_format_42.o,reg_import_42.o,net_registry_util_42.o,net_help_common_42.o
-> net}
 ?-> task failed (err #1):
 ??? {task: cc_link 
cmd_vfs_145.o,vfstest_145.o,vfstest_chain_145.o,smbreadline_1.o -> vfstest}
 ?-> task failed (err #1):
 ??? {task: cc_link 
generic_15.o,hive_15.o,diff_15.o,registry_15.o,rap_10.o,rpc_10.o,printing_10.o,sam_10.o,smbreadline_1.o,util_smb_1.o,qfsinfo_4.o,qfileinfo_4.o,setfileinfo_4.o,search_4.o,close_4.o,open_4.o,mkdir_4.o,oplock_4.o,notify_4.o,mux_4.o,ioctl_4.o,chkpath_4.o,unlink_4.o,read_4.o,context_4.o,session_4.o,write_4.o,lock_4.o,pingpong_4.o,lockbench_4.o,lookuprate_4.o,tconrate_4.o,openbench_4.o,rename_4.o,eas_4.o,streams_4.o,acls_4.o,seek_4.o,samba3hide_4.o,samba3misc_4.o,composite_4.o,raw_4.o,offline_4.o,clilsa_2.o,ndr_witness_c_165.o,common_20.o,basic_20.o,schema_20.o,uptodatevector_20.o,cldap_20.o,netlogon_20.o,cldapbench_20.o,ldap_sort_20.o,nested_search_20.o,ndr_browser_c_134.o,ntlmssp_14.o,pac_14.o,smbencrypt_14.o,ndr_rap_45.o,ndr_rap_45.o,smbtorture_30.o,torture_30.o,shell_30.o,drs_init_1.o,drs_util_1.o,prefixmap_tests_1.o,schemainfo_tests_1.o,dssync_1.o,msds_intid_1.o,gpo_1.o,apply_1.o,query_22.o,register_22.o,wins_22.o,winsbench_22.o,winsreplication_22.o,dgram_22.o,nbt_22.o,wb_utils_1.o,iconv_1.o,testsuite_1.o,messaging_1.o,irpc_1.o,binding_string_1.o,idtree_1.o,dlinklist_1.o,testsuite_1.o,testsuite_1.o,strlist_1.o,binsearch_1.o,str_1.o,time_1.o,asn1_tests_1.o,data_blob_1.o,file_1.o,genrand_1.o,testsuite_1.o,charset_1.o,convert_string_1.o,sddl_1.o,testsuite_1.o,testsuite_1.o,share_1.o,loadparm_1.o,simple_1.o,local_1.o,dbspeed_1.o,torture_1.o,ldb_1.o,dsdb_dn_1.o,schema_syntax_1.o,anonymous_shared_1.o,strv_1.o,strv_util_1.o,util_1.o,util_str_escape_1.o,tfork_1.o,verif_trailer_1.o,nss_tests_1.o,fsrvp_state_1.o,ndr_unixinfo_c_133.o,nbio_16.o,nbench_16.o,ndr_remact_c_152.o,join_8.o,lsa_8.o,forest_trust_8.o,lsa_lookup_8.o,session_key_8.o,echo_8.o,dfs_8.o,drsuapi_8.o,drsuapi_w2k8_8.o,drsuapi_cracknames_8.o,dsgetinfo_8.o,spoolss_8.o,spoolss_win_8.o,spoolss_access_8.o,unixinfo_8.o,samr_8.o,samr_accessmask_8.o,samr_priv_8.o,wkssvc_8.o,srvsvc_8.o,svcctl_8.o,atsvc_8.o,eventlog_8.o,epmapper_8.o,winreg_8.o,initshutdown_8.o,oxidresolve_8.o,remact_8.o,mgmt_8.o,scanner_8.o,autoidl_8.o,countcalls_8.o,testjoin_8.o,schannel_8.o,netlogon_8.o,remote_pac_8.o,samlogon_8.o,samsync_8.o,dssetup_8.o,alter_context_8.o,bench_8.o,samba3rpc_8.o,rpc_8.o,async_bind_8.o,handles_8.o,frsapi_8.o,object_uuid_8.o,ntsvcs_8.o,browser_8.o,bind_8.o,fsrvp_8.o,clusapi_8.o,witness_8.o,iremotewinspool_8.o,rap_1.o,ndr_dssetup_c_146.o,ntp_signd_26.o,vfs_28.o,fruit_28.o,acl_xattr_28.o,winsrepl_10.o,base_2.o,misc_2.o,scanner_2.o,utable_2.o,charset_2.o,mangle_test_2.o,denytest_2.o,aliases_2.o,locking_2.o,secleak_2.o,rename_2.o,dir_2.o,delete_2.o,unlink_2.o,disconnect_2.o,delaywrite_2.o,attr_2.o,properties_2.o,ndr_backupkey_c_161.o,ndr_rot_c_119.o,unix_18.o,whoami_18.o,unix_info2_18.o,acls_1.o,compound_1.o,connect_1.o,create_1.o,credits_1.o,delete-on-close_1.o,dir_1.o,dosmode_1.o,durable_open_1.o,durable_v2_open_1.o,getinfo_1.o,ioctl_1.o,lease_1.o,lease_break_handler_1.o,lock_1.o,maxfid_1.o,maxwrite_1.o,notify_1.o,notify_disabled_1.o,oplock_1.o,read_1.o,rename_1.o,replay_1.o,scan_1.o,session_1.o,setinfo_1.o,sharemode_1.o,smb2_1.o,streams_1.o,util_1.o,popt_common_4.o,libnetapi_1.o,libnetapi_user_1.o,libnetapi_group_1.o,libnetapi_server_1.o,echo_1.o,smbtorture.objlist.empty_32.o,domaindfs_12.o,common_12.o,popt_credentials_5.o,ndr_frsapi_c_128.o,libnet_24.o,utils_24.o,userinfo_24.o,userman_24.o,groupinfo_24.o,groupman_24.o,domain_24.o,libnet_lookup_24.o,libnet_user_24.o,libnet_group_24.o,libnet_share_24.o,libnet_rpc_24.o,libnet_domain_24.o,libnet_BecomeDC_24.o,ndr_fsrvp_c_164.o,srv_fss_state_13.o,testsuite_4.o,strptime_4.o,os2_delete_4.o,getifaddrs_4.o,ndr_6.o,winreg_6.o,atsvc_6.o,lsa_6.o,epmap_6.o,dfs_6.o,netlogon_6.o,drsuapi_6.o,spoolss_6.o,ntprinting_6.o,samr_6.o,dfsblob_6.o,drsblobs_6.o,nbt_6.o,ntlmssp_6.o,string_6.o,backupkey_6.o,witness_6.o,clusapi_6.o,negoex_6.o,krb5pac_6.o,winspool_6.o,cabinet_6.o,charset_6.o,ndr_winspool_c_136.o,echo_1.o,ndr_fsrvp_state_186.o,ndr_oxidresolver_c_151.o,libsmbclient_1.o,md4test_2.o,md5test_2.o,hmacmd5test_2.o,aes_cmac_128_test_2.o,aes_ccm_128_test_2.o,aes_gcm_128_test_2.o,ndr_clusapi_c_166.o,winbind_1.o,struct_based_1.o,wbclient_1.o
-> smbtorture}
make: *** [all] Error 1


I hope that someone can help me, thanks in advance!

-- 
Bruno Lorente

On Mon, 2020-08-03 at 10:05 +0200, Bruno Lorente Cantarero via samba
wrote:
> Hi everyone,
> 
> I'm trying to compile samba from macOS Catalina from several days
> ago 
> without success, I'm a newbie on this kind of stuff over mac, so...
> It 
> will probably be a noob error, but I'm lost.
>From the fact that random patches have to be applied to the fact that
Homebrew pulled their package of it I suggest that statistically about
people have done this.

If you like a challenge, you could probably get past these issues, but
be warned that even running an upstream Samba release on FreeBSD has
had its challenges from time to time, and this will be harder.

It has been a long time since I remember an active developer doing the
work to make MacOS go, and most of that went into the darwin port, not
upstream so has been lost.

Sorry!

Andrew Bartlett

-- 
Andrew Bartlett                       https://samba.org/~abartlet/
Authentication Developer, Samba Team  https://samba.org
Samba Developer, Catalyst IT          
https://catalyst.net.nz/services/samba

Hi Andrew,

Many thanks for your fast reply!


Ok, I understand the point, anyway I'll try to keep going on this.


Thank you very much!

--

Bruno Lorente

El 3/8/20 a las 10:22, Andrew Bartlett escribi?:
> On Mon, 2020-08-03 at 10:05 +0200, Bruno Lorente Cantarero via samba
> wrote:
>> Hi everyone,
>>
>> I'm trying to compile samba from macOS Catalina from several days
>> ago
>> without success, I'm a newbie on this kind of stuff over mac, so...
>> It
>> will probably be a noob error, but I'm lost.
>  From the fact that random patches have to be applied to the fact that
> Homebrew pulled their package of it I suggest that statistically about
> people have done this.
>
> If you like a challenge, you could probably get past these issues, but
> be warned that even running an upstream Samba release on FreeBSD has
> had its challenges from time to time, and this will be harder.
>
> It has been a long time since I remember an active developer doing the
> work to make MacOS go, and most of that went into the darwin port, not
> upstream so has been lost.
>
> Sorry!
>
> Andrew Bartlett
>

On Mon, Aug 03, 2020 at 08:22:21PM +1200, Andrew Bartlett via samba
wrote:
> On Mon, 2020-08-03 at 10:05 +0200, Bruno Lorente Cantarero via samba
> wrote:
> > Hi everyone,
> > 
> > I'm trying to compile samba from macOS Catalina from several days
> > ago 
> > without success, I'm a newbie on this kind of stuff over mac,
so...
> > It 
> > will probably be a noob error, but I'm lost.
> 
> From the fact that random patches have to be applied to the fact that
> Homebrew pulled their package of it I suggest that statistically about
> people have done this.
> 
> If you like a challenge, you could probably get past these issues, but
> be warned that even running an upstream Samba release on FreeBSD has
> had its challenges from time to time, and this will be harder.
> 
> It has been a long time since I remember an active developer doing the
> work to make MacOS go, and most of that went into the darwin port, not
> upstream so has been lost.
> 
> Sorry!
I will have some news on this shortly (where "shortly" may mean
a few months :-). There is interest at Google on making this
work for.. "reasons" :-).