Xen devel - Feb 2012 - Cloning a VM and copy-on-write deduplicating memory using CoW page sharing in Xen 4+

Hey all,
Hey Andres,

I''m looking to clone a VM into several extremely-similar VMs, and
I''m
hoping to also make use of your lovely new CoW page sharing capabilities in
Xen 4.

From my understanding of a previous thread where Andres described the
process of sharing/coalescing memory between VMs, it sounds like I will
need to "manually" coalesce each page using a homebrew tool of mine. 
The
issue I have with doing this is it seems like I''d need to pause, save
mem,
load mem in a new VM, coalesce, and resume two VMs, which seems painful and
wasteful of a process for cloning!

Is there an easier way to do this, or should we add a new feature for CoW
cloning of VMs in Xen via a userspace tool?

Thanks,
Pat Wilbur & team


--
Patrick F. Wilbur
Researcher, Consultant, Educator,
Computer Science Graduate at Clarkson University

DONE RIGHT THE FIRST TIME: Consulting and hiring information:
http://pdub.net/consulting/ & http://pdub.net/hiring/

patrick.wilbur@gmail.com
wilburpf@clarkson.edu

Check out our book: http://runningxen.com
My website: http://pdub.net


_______________________________________________
Xen-devel mailing list
Xen-devel@lists.xensource.com
http://lists.xensource.com/xen-devel

> Hey all,
> Hey Andres,
>
> I''m looking to clone a VM into several extremely-similar VMs, and
I''m
> hoping to also make use of your lovely new CoW page sharing capabilities
> in
> Xen 4.
>
> From my understanding of a previous thread where Andres described the
> process of sharing/coalescing memory between VMs, it sounds like I will
> need to "manually" coalesce each page using a homebrew tool of
mine.  The
> issue I have with doing this is it seems like I''d need to pause,
save mem,
> load mem in a new VM, coalesce, and resume two VMs, which seems painful
> and
> wasteful of a process for cloning!
Patrick,
that is indeed painful and wasteful. That is why we added
xc_memshr_add_to_physmap. Now you can do Potemkin-/SnowFlock-like cloning
in a few lines of code. You still want the source VM to be paused,
obviously.

Yuengling is my favourite US beer ;)

Andres
>
> Is there an easier way to do this, or should we add a new feature for CoW
> cloning of VMs in Xen via a userspace tool?
>
> Thanks,
> Pat Wilbur & team
>
>
> --
> Patrick F. Wilbur
> Researcher, Consultant, Educator,
> Computer Science Graduate at Clarkson University
>
> DONE RIGHT THE FIRST TIME: Consulting and hiring information:
> http://pdub.net/consulting/ & http://pdub.net/hiring/
>
> patrick.wilbur@gmail.com
> wilburpf@clarkson.edu
>
> Check out our book: http://runningxen.com
> My website: http://pdub.net
>