Flac - Sep 2004 - [Flac-users] Can I use Vorbis comment on ogg - flac?

I was wondering if I could use tOGGer in ogg-flac files. So I asked
Josh. His answer is quoted below (spoiler: doesn't think so). And when I
tried tOGGer it didn't work. So I guess his right. But I wanted to know
if his speculation is right (i.e. vorbiscomment saves comments in the
first Vorbis packet). And if so why. I´m not sure how is Theora working.
But it seemed logical to me that having a the comments on the ogg file
should be a good thing. Let's say that we encode a movie. Iy may be nice
to be able to put comments on each data stream (audio, video, text) but
the file as such should have some comments. Is this not possible so you
can concatenate two ogg files to get a valid ogg file?

Regards,
Alejandro Belluscio
> --- "Alejandro G. Belluscio" <baldusi@uol.com.ar> wrote:
>> Hello flac-users,
>>   I'm storing my ripped CDs on FLAC until Vorbis 1.0 gets out
>> (supposedly RSN). But I want to enter the vorbis comment just once.
>> Since I'll use ogg bitstream for both files, I was wondering if I
>> could
>> use vorbiscomment or tOGGer on ogg-flac files? Is there any tool
>> (besides de pipe) to convert ogg-flac to ogg-vorbis?
> 
> I don't think so.  I think comments go in Vorbis packets, not
> in the Ogg layer.
> 
> As for a transcoder, no, I think even sonice does it through
> pipes.
> 
> Josh
<p>--- >8 ----
List archives:  http://www.xiph.org/archives/
Ogg project homepage: http://www.xiph.org/ogg/
To unsubscribe from this list, send a message to
'vorbis-request@xiph.org'
containing only the word 'unsubscribe' in the body.  No subject is
needed.
Unsubscribe messages sent to the list will be ignored/filtered.

Hello flac-users,
  I'm storing my ripped CDs on FLAC until Vorbis 1.0 gets out
(supposedly RSN). But I want to enter the vorbis comment just once.
Since I'll use ogg bitstream for both files, I was wondering if I could
use vorbiscomment or tOGGer on ogg-flac files? Is there any tool
(besides de pipe) to convert ogg-flac to ogg-vorbis?

Best regards,
Alejandro Belluscio

--- "Alejandro G. Belluscio" <baldusi@uol.com.ar>
wrote:
> Hello flac-users,
>   I'm storing my ripped CDs on FLAC until Vorbis 1.0 gets out
> (supposedly RSN). But I want to enter the vorbis comment just once.
> Since I'll use ogg bitstream for both files, I was wondering if I
> could
> use vorbiscomment or tOGGer on ogg-flac files? Is there any tool
> (besides de pipe) to convert ogg-flac to ogg-vorbis?
I don't think so.  I think comments go in Vorbis packets, not
in the Ogg layer.

As for a transcoder, no, I think even sonice does it through
pipes.

Josh


__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Autos - Get free new car price quotes
http://autos.yahoo.com