theora dev - Aug 2005 - libtheora Bitrate Problem

Hello,
  I'm not sure if this list is the proper place for this post; please 
correct me if it is not.
  I am attempting to use libtheora and I have been looking through the 
examples in the distribution

  Excerpt from encoder_example.c  --

    case 'V':
      video_r=rint(atof(optarg)*1000);
      if(video_r<45000 || video_r>2000000) {
        fprintf(stderr,"Illegal video bitrate (choose 45kbps through
2000kbps)\n");
        exit(1);
      }
      video_q=0;
     break;

 I assume 'kbps' is Kilobits Per Second (kbit/s) and 
*theora_info.target_bitrate* is in Bits Per Second. 
 If this is true then shouldn't the argument (optarg) be multiplied by 
1024 and not 1000?  Or does it matter?

Thanks,

    Draco
    draco@dragonsguild.net


 
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL:
http://lists.xiph.org/pipermail/theora-dev/attachments/20050805/53b51693/attachment.htm

On Fri, Aug 05, 2005 at 01:52:14AM -0500, Draco wrote:
> I assume 'kbps' is Kilobits Per Second (kbit/s) and 
> *theora_info.target_bitrate* is in Bits Per Second. 
> If this is true then shouldn't the argument (optarg) be multiplied by 
> 1024 and not 1000?  Or does it matter?
Well, it doesn't really matter, but traditionally bitrates are in base
10 units instead of base 2 like filesize. So a kilobyte of data is 1024
bytes, but 1 kbps is 1000 bits per second. so at 1 kbps it takes 8.192
seconds to send 1 kilobyte.

I think it's because the use of kbps in digital telecommunications
predates/evolved separately from the standardization on powers of 2
in computer data storage.

All of which makes the practice of using powers of 2 in compressed
audio bitrates quite strange. A 128 kbps MP3 file is 128000 bits per
second, or 2^7 * 10^3, not 2^17 or 131072 bits per second.

 -r