Hello, I'm on a multi-subnet, multi-workgroup campus network, and I'm trying to build a SMB indexer. I've run into a roadblock as I can't browse any computers which are not on my subnet (i.e. they don't come up in `smbclient -L "A LOCAL SERVER"`). I can connect to computers for which I know the IP addresses, but that doesn't help me much, since addresses are assigned dynamically. So, as it is now, I can only index the 60 or so computers in my subnet, and the 25 other subnets go unindexed. I've read tons of information about the problem, but none of it helps me because I'm not the network administrator, and those who are don't really want to be facilitating file sharing. Here is a list of things I've ruled out: Run a WINS server: ...No way to make everyone people use my WINS server. Fetch remote browse lists from LMBs in other subnets: ...I can't find out the IPs of the remote LMBs. Sync browse lists with LMBs in other subnets: ...Can't find out their IPs, and they're not samba boxen! Use remote broadcasting to find remote LMBs: ...Routers won't allow it. Am I overlooking anything in these possobilities? Also, I've noticed that when Windows 9x clients have only the TCP/IP protocol installed, they can browse the same set of computers that I can. However, when they install IPX/SPX, they can see outside of their subnets. Can anyone explain this? Thanks in advance for your help, I really appreciate it! -samuel
Barry Dexter A. Gonzaga
2000-Oct-23 10:53 UTC
same old multiple subnets problem... with a twist!
> Run a WINS server: > ...No way to make everyone people use my WINS server. > > Fetch remote browse lists from LMBs in other subnets: > ...I can't find out the IPs of the remote LMBs. > > Sync browse lists with LMBs in other subnets: > ...Can't find out their IPs, and they're not samba boxen! > > Use remote broadcasting to find remote LMBs: > ...Routers won't allow it. > > Am I overlooking anything in these possobilities? >if you cannnot be wins server of other boxes and you are not on the same subnet and lmb on the other subnets doesnt use tcp/ip, i dont know if u could browse lists with them. i may be wrong. ymmv> Also, I've noticed that when Windows 9x clients have only the TCP/IP > protocol installed, they can browse the same set of computers that I can. > However, when they install IPX/SPX, they can see outside of their subnets. > Can anyone explain this?ipx/spx is used by novell, and works because it likes to broadcast[shout] to all computers, samba runs atop tcp/ip and does <b>not</b> understand ipx/spx so they can't communicate.> Thanks in advance for your help, I really appreciate it! > -samuelvery much welcome. --barryg