I?ve got an ATA with v2.16 configured as per JTodd?s guide having problems re-registering. The only thing particular to this ATA (I?ve got several all configured the same way but one of them have problems) is that is on a public IP. I have commented NAT=1 and canreinvite=no on sip.conf The ATA registers fine the first time but on the following registration updates, * gives me the the warning: "Registration fail for ....." and it continues trying to register unsuccesfully over and over. If I do sip show peers, the ATA is not there, of course. Looking at the archives I?ve found that on the new version (2.16.1) they have fixed a bug which is somewhat related: CSCeb17953 The Cisco ATA stops the registration process if it receives an unexpected response to a REGISTER request. HAs anyone had this problem before with 2.16? Woudl 2.16.1 fix this ? Thanks in advance -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.digium.com/pipermail/asterisk-users/attachments/20030914/d6297d80/attachment.htm
>I?ve got an ATA with v2.16 configured as per JTodd?s guide having >problems re-registering. The only thing particular to this >ATA (I?ve got several all configured the same way but one of them >have problems) is that is on a public IP. I have commented NAT=1 and >canreinvite=no on sip.conf > >The ATA registers fine the first time but on the following >registration updates, * gives me the the warning: "Registration fail >for ....." and it continues trying to register unsuccesfully over >and over. If I do sip show peers, the ATA is not there, of course. > >Looking at the archives I?ve found that on the new version (2.16.1) >they have fixed a bug which is somewhat related: > >CSCeb17953 The Cisco ATA stops the registration process if it >receives an unexpected response to a REGISTER request. > >HAs anyone had this problem before with 2.16? Woudl 2.16.1 fix this ? > >Thanks in advanceI would suggest upgrading, as this has been (apparently) solved in 2.16.1, according to both the note that you reference, and my anecdotal experiences. JT
i assume we talking about ata and sip. 2.14 and 2.15 does not have this bug. I have the same problem w/ fw v2.16 when getting anything else then "100 trying" or "200 OK" on the register callleg, which either results in stopping to register (i power cycle the ata or go to the web config and update once then) or registering with a malformed request uri "REGISTER sip:: SIP/2.0" where host and port disapeared. i suggest to upgrade the fw Michael Dan Fernandez wrote:> I?ve got an ATA with v2.16 configured as per JTodd?s guide having > problems re-registering. The only thing particular to this ATA (I?ve > got several all configured the same way but one of them have > problems) is that is on a public IP. I have commented NAT=1 and > canreinvite=no on sip.conf > > The ATA registers fine the first time but on the following > registration updates, * gives me the the warning: "Registration fail > for ....." and it continues trying to register unsuccesfully over and > over. If I do sip show peers, the ATA is not there, of course. > > Looking at the archives I?ve found that on the new version (2.16.1) > they have fixed a bug which is somewhat related: > > CSCeb17953 The Cisco ATA stops the registration process if it > receives an unexpected response to a REGISTER request. > HAs anyone had this problem before with 2.16? Woudl 2.16.1 fix this ? > > Thanks in advance > > > >-------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.digium.com/pipermail/asterisk-users/attachments/20030914/9b67f155/attachment.htm