dovecot - Dec 2005 - dotlock & NFS

Hello,

is dotlock supposed to work with NFS? I noticed that the default-locking 
method causes problems even with nfslockd started.

Regards
Marten

On Mon, 5 Dec 2005, Marten Lehmann wrote:
> Hello,
>
> is dotlock supposed to work with NFS? I noticed that the default-locking 
> method causes problems even with nfslockd started.
I'm using fcntl locking over NFS and it seems to work fine.

This is using Linux servers and NetApp filers,  The kernel is 2.6.x
and lockd runs as a kernel thread.  It should work with userspace lockd
though.  Make sure that rpc.statd is running as well. (if it's needed,
it isn't with 2.6 kernels, not sure about *BSD, Solaris, etc.)

I haven't used it, but dotlocking should work.

Todd

On Mon, Dec 05, 2005 at 12:25:49PM +0100, Marten Lehmann wrote:
> is dotlock supposed to work with NFS? I noticed that the default-locking 
> method causes problems even with nfslockd started.
Dotlocking is the only sane locking mechanism over NFS. fcntl locks often
work, too, depending on the clients and servers, but there are various
corner cases where lockd (NFS's locking mechanism) fails... For instance,
when a client, holding locks, goes offline. If the client (as identified by
its ipaddress) stays offline, lockd is supposed to hold the locks forever.
Whether your lockd does depends :P Dotlocks use NFS (not lockd) metadata
semantics, and they work on all NFS combinations I've seen.

For small installations, or situations where a few stale lock files isn't
that big a deal, fcntl locks are fine (if the servers and clients all
co-operate.) If you want something that scales well or is less of a hassle
in large installations, or if fcntl doesn't seem to work right, use
dotlocking. Most importantly, though, make sure everything that locks the
same file is using the same locking mechanism. So, if you use mbox
mailboxes, and procmail to deliver to them, or pine to read them while
dovecot may be reading them too, make sure they all lock the same way.

-- 
Thomas Wouters <thomas at xs4all.net>

Hi! I'm a .signature virus! copy me into your .signature file to help me
spread!