Virtualization - Mar 2021 - Question about sg_count_fuse_req() in linux/fs/fuse/virtio_fs.c

On Wed, Mar 17, 2021 at 01:12:01PM -0500, Connor Kuehl
wrote:
> Hi,
> 
> I've been familiarizing myself with the virtiofs guest kernel module
and I'm
> trying to better understand how virtiofs maps a FUSE request into
> scattergather lists.
> 
> sg_count_fuse_req() starts knowing that there will be at least one in
> header, as shown here (which makes sense):
> 
>         unsigned int size, total_sgs = 1 /* fuse_in_header */;
> 
> However, I'm confused about this snippet right beneath it:
> 
>         if (args->in_numargs - args->in_pages)
>                 total_sgs += 1;
> 
> What is the significance of the sg that is needed in the cases where this
> branch is taken? I'm not sure what its relationship is with
args->in_numargs
> since it will increment total_sgs regardless args->in_numargs is 3, 2,
or
> even 1 if args->in_pages is false.
Hi Conor,

I think all the in args are being mapped into a single scatter gather
element and that's why it does not matter whether in_numargs is 3, 2 or 1.
They will be mapped in a single element.

sg_init_fuse_args()
{
        len = fuse_len_args(numargs - argpages, args);
        if (len)
                sg_init_one(&sg[total_sgs++], argbuf, len);
}

        out_sgs += sg_init_fuse_args(&sg[out_sgs], req,
                                     (struct fuse_arg *)args->in_args,
                                     args->in_numargs, args->in_pages,
                                     req->argbuf, &argbuf_used);

When we are sending some data in some pages, then we set args->in_pages
to true. And in that case, last element of args->in_args[] contains the
total size of bytes in additional pages we are sending and is not part
of in_args being mapped to scatter gather element. That's why this
check.

	if (args->in_numargs - args->in_pages)
		total_sgs += 1;

Not sure when we will have a case where args->in_numargs = 1 and
args->in_pages=true. Do we ever hit that.

Thanks
Vivek
> 
> Especially since the block right below it counts pages if args->in_pages
is
> true:
> 
>         if (args->in_pages) {
>                 size = args->in_args[args->in_numargs - 1].size;
>                 total_sgs += sg_count_fuse_pages(ap->descs,
ap->num_pages,
>                                                  size);
>         }
> 
> The rest of the routine goes on similarly but for the 'out'
components.
> 
> I doubt incrementing 'total_sgs' in the first if-statement I showed
above is
> vestigial, I just think my mental model of what is happening here is
> incomplete.
> 
> Any clarification is much appreciated!
> 
> Connor
>