rsync - Oct 2007 - [feature request] Modify --backup option to make backups on source side, too

Hello,

Can you please modify the backup options to work together with  
--remove-source-files so I'm able to create a reliable "move between  
hosts" script?

If --backup is specified, the files to be deleted should be renamed on  
the source side. If --backup-dir is specified, they should be moved  
there, etc.

If this already works, please update the documentation accordingly :-)

Thanks a lot,

-- 
Aaron "Optimizer" Digulla a.k.a. Philmann Dark
"It's not the universe that's limited, it's our imagination.
Follow me and I'll show you something beyond the limits."
http://www.pdark.de/

On 10/15/07, Aaron Digulla <digulla@hepe.com>
wrote:
> Can you please modify the backup options to work together with
> --remove-source-files so I'm able to create a reliable "move
between
> hosts" script?
The patch "patches/source-backup.diff" in the source tree adds an
option --source-backup to do this.  You can compile your own copy of
rsync containing the patch and then use that option.

Matt

On 10/15/07, Aaron Digulla <digulla@hepe.com>
wrote:
> Thanks for the input. If this wasn't for a production system, I'd
do
> that :-) Why don't you apply the patch the release version?
Because the patch is a quick hack to serve a niche need, so the
benefit of saving people who need source backups a few steps does not
outweigh the cost of having it clutter up (and conceivably
destabilize) the main version of rsync for everyone else.

I think the model of a main version with the most important features
plus distributed patches for various extra features is an excellent
way to deliver a clean, stable rsync to the typical user but still
have implementations of the extra features available when needed.  In
fact, beginning in September 2005, I used a copy of rsync including a
patch for ACL support for nearly all copies on my computer.  The patch
was a complete hack and I really cared about ACLs, so I helped Wayne
improve the patch to the point where it was just as clean and stable
as the main code; then, in March 2007, Wayne elected to roll the patch
into the main version.  In the same way, I encourage you to test and
begin using the source-backup patch now if it suits your needs; if you
want the patch added to the main version, you can help make that more
likely by improving it.

Matt