openssh unix dev - Feb 2010 - S_ISSOCK fails in openssh >= 5.1

Starting with openssh 5.1 the following code fails (when executed on a 
remote host)... prior to 5.0 this worked, ie S_ISSOCK says STDIN is a 
socket.

   struct stat s;
   fstat(STDIN_FILENO, &s);
   if (S_ISSOCK(s.st_mode))
     // STDIN is a socket
   else
     // STDIN is not a socket

Soo... if I have a command on a remote host that includes the above code 
and I ssh to the remote host and execute the command, S_ISSOCK will fail if 
the ssh server is >= 5.1.

Is this change on purpose or a bug?

On Mon, 22 Feb 2010, petesea at bigfoot.com wrote:
> Starting with openssh 5.1 the following code fails (when executed on a
remote
> host)... prior to 5.0 this worked, ie S_ISSOCK says STDIN is a socket.
> 
>   struct stat s;
>   fstat(STDIN_FILENO, &s);
>   if (S_ISSOCK(s.st_mode))
>     // STDIN is a socket
>   else
>     // STDIN is not a socket
> 
> Soo... if I have a command on a remote host that includes the above code
and I
> ssh to the remote host and execute the command, S_ISSOCK will fail if the
ssh
> server is >= 5.1.
> 
> Is this change on purpose or a bug?
Yes, it is on purpose to better support independant signalling of input/output
closure. The channel between a shell/program and sshd is an implementation
detail and is not part of any promised interface, so it is unwise to
depend upon it. 

If you want to detect if your program is running under sshd, then you might
want to try testing for the presence of a SSH_CLIENT environment variable.

-d