similar to: NHW Project - lower quality settings - high compression

Hello, I have re-tested -l4 high compression setting and it's clear that it lacks of precision on degraded, rather blurred images. So I don't know if it is a good idea to base the other lower quality settings (-l5,-l6,...) on -l4 setting.I have tested the NHW codec against x265, x264, Daala, WebP, Rududu, DLI and it's clear that at high compression these very good codecs have more

Hello all, It's me again.Just a quick message to tell that I finally do not agree that HEVC (don't have tested AOM AV1 for now) is better than the NHW codec at mid compression. Last night, I dowloaded 30 images of Star Wars Rogue One on the web and I made another comparison with x265 (HEVC) for mid compression (-l2 to h2 settings for the NHW codec). Visually, I prefer the results of NHW

Hello, I have improved a little the NHW codec.I have improved the dequantization in the wavelet HH band, and little improved the -l2 (and lower) quality setting.I have also added a -l3 lower quality setting (-15Ko, exp), I have increased the quantization for this other setting, and I start to remove higher wavelet coefficients, but this is not optimal... The artifacts start to be noticeable for

I don't mind at all. I imagine there are more people like me out there who have been following your work, but haven't said anything. I agree that a series of pages explaining how things work may lead to more contributions. At the very least it would lead to more people being better educated on how wavelets work in image compression. But, this is your project, if you don't have the

Hi David! Many thanks for your very encouraging and kind feedback!!! (Hope you don't mind that I made your post public on the Theora channel). I try to be the more sincere as I can in my posts.Some people suggested me to make demo pages to explain how the codec works step by step, and I realize that it would be good, because certainly it will show that the NHW codec is not that complex and

Hello, I have finally added 2 lower quality settings for the NHW codec: -l1 (-5Ko) and -l2 (-10Ko).I use a quantization of 0.935 and 0.88 (kind of quantization), and I decrease residual coding on the first order wavelet image. I have updated the demo page: http://nhwcodec.blogspot.com/ . These 2 lower quality settings are still experimental.If you could find time, would be interested in any

Hello, Just a very quick message to let you know that I have added a higher quality setting (-h2, +10Ko) and I have added now residual coding on the 512x256 wavelet image for the higher settings.Precision is a little better.-I also still apply the post-processing function on the 512x256 wavelet image for now.- Here is the link for the binaries (as I can not link them in my blog for now):

Hello, For those interested, I have added a -l4 high compression setting to the NHW codec ( http://nhwcodec.blogspot.com/ ).This setting is very experimental, I have boosted the sharpness for this one, but it can lack of precision on low contrast areas. This setting still maintains a good neatness and when it will be validated, I will then make a new 0.1.4 version for the NHW Project. High

Hello, With -l5 quality setting, I have learned that I can increase wavelet coeff threshold to 12 in the HH band without noticeable difference in the reconstructed images.With this processing, I win in average 1Ko in the compressed .nhw files, and so I can raise the quantization for -l1->-l4 settings (0.935->0.955,0.88->0.9,0.87->0.89) and so these settings are now better, there is a

Hello, I have just tested new next lower quality settings (-l3 and -l4), I can diminish residual coding but if I increase wavelet coeffs threshold there is more aliasing.And even in the current mid quality settings there is some aliasing, this is the big drawback of the NHW codec. SPIHT algorithm is good for that as for example Rududu codec doesn't have aliasing at all at mid compression and

Hello, I've found some time to get back to the NHW Project.In fact a Xiph forum member told me that even if I will start a new job, he hopes that I will still continue to develop a little the NHW Project, on my spare time.I told him that I would furthermore spend my spare time on the NHW Project if a community around the project could emerge... and he told me that certainly the best way for

Hello, I have improved quality for -l1->-l4 settings.I have properly set up the wavelet coeff threshold of the dead-zone according to the different wavelet subbands, I have then saved another 1Ko per .nhw files without noticeable difference and so I have raised again the quantization.The reconstructed images have now a better precision and still a good neatness. Update at:

Hello, I spoke a little quickly when I proposed a £1000 rewards... because there is still some "easy" processing to increase compression in the NHW codec, like increasing wavelet coefficients threshold, decreasing again residual coding.I will try to code it tomorrow and this weekend, and will let you know what it gives. A new idea I'm thinking of not to have too much aliasing and

Hello, The -l8 "very high compression" setting I posted was not really good.Now I have corrected and improved it, and now the -l8 quality setting is really better, more precision and more neatness. I think now it is a good setting, and I have started to compare it with x265 and it can be now competitive. More at: http://nhwcodec.blogspot.com/ Do not hesitate to test it and give me

Hello, For those interested, I have added a -l8 "very high compression" setting to the NHW Project. I have added an experimental processing to remove details and preserve neatness.I have also now a fast estimation of entropy of wavelet coefficients and I use it accordingly to the image complexity but it is a very first version... With these new processings, the entropy coding schemes

Hello, No advance for now on the NHW codec, I am still working on a new quantization scheme to scale down the compression ratios but without luck... Any advice, idea is very welcome.I will also have to correctly code the wavelet filerbank and process on rows and columns and suppress the image transposition (this is for long overdue)... will win few cycles... there are other parts to speed up (in

Hello, I have improved quality for -l3,-l4,-l5 settings.I have diminished residual coding and I have raised again quantization.These settings are now better. Update at: http://nhwcodec.blogspot.com/ The NHW Project with this version starts to be competitive at high compression with x265. Any feedback welcome! Cheers, Raphael -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was

Hello, These last 2 months I have been in contact with a very impressive and friendly engineer from Intel who has written an article on my codec and the 4-5 new codecs in general that competes with HEVC.He finally answered me that as Intel is a founding member of the Alliance for Open Media and chairs several MPEG WG around HEVC, they won't be able to put extra resources on the NHW Project.So

Hello, I have made a new version of NHW.This one has more neatness and more precision for -l4 to -l11 quality settings, which are the general-purpose compression settings.It is actually just one parameter better tuning based on my visual evaluations (no real new developments... it was 14 months now that I did not develop the NHW Project...). Files size is just a little bigger, but we can still

Hello, Ok that's right HEVC and AOM AV1 are better than the NHW codec, even at mid compression.I only tested my codec with quite neat images, hence the good results, but on more blurred, more compressed images, HEVC and AOM AV1 are definitely better, they are also exceptionnal at high compression. So, yes that's right, the NHW codec has very little chance to penetrate the market, it is