similar to: Assessing overdispersion and using quasi model with lmer, possible?

I have a few questions relating to overdispersion in a sex ratio data set that I am working with (note that I already have an analysis with GLMMs for fixed effects, this is just to estimate dispersion). The response variable is binomial because nestlings can only be male or female. I have samples of 1-5 nestlings from each nest (individuals within a nest are not independent, so the response

Sorry about re-posting this, it never went out to the mailing list when I posted this to r-help forum on Nabble and was pending for a few days, now that I am subscribe to the mailing list I hope that this goes out: I've been a viewer of this forum for a while and it has helped out a lot, but this is my first time posting something. I am running glm models for richness and abundances. For

Dear R users, I am trying to fully understand the difference between estimating overdispersion with glm.nb() from MASS compared to glm(..., family = quasipoisson). It seems that (i) the coefficient estimates are different and also (ii) the summary() method for glm.nb suggests that overdispersion is taken to be one: "Dispersion parameter for Negative Binomial(0.9695) family taken to be

I am looking for the correct commands to do the following things: 1. I have a binomial logistic regression model and i want to test for overdispersion. 2. If I do indeed have overdispersion i need to then run a quasi-binomial model, but I'm not sure of the command. 3. I can get the residuals of the model, but i need to then apply a shapiro wilk test to test them. Does anyone know the command

I've been poking around with GLMs (on which I am *not* an expert) on behalf of a student, particularly binomial (standard logit link) nested models with overdispersion. I have one possible bug to report (but I'm not confident enough to be *sure* it's a bug); one comment on the general inconsistency that seems to afflict the various functions for dealing with overdispersion in GLMs

Hi, there are a lot of messages dealing with overdispersion, but I couldn't find anything about how to test for overdispersion. I applied a GAM with binomial distribution on my presence/absence data, and would like to check for overdispersion. Does anyone know the command? Many thanks, Anna -- View this message in context:

Hey Buddy, Hope you have been doing well since last contact. If you have the answer to the following question, please let me know. If you have chance to travel up north. let me know. best, -Sean ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From: Sean Zhang <seanecon@gmail.com> Date: Sat, Apr 11, 2009 at 12:12 PM Subject: question related to fitting overdispersion count data using lmer

How can I eliminate the overdispersion for binary data apart the use of the quasibinomial? help me Eva Iannario ------------------------------------------------------ Passa a Infostrada. ADSL e Telefono senza limiti e senza canone Telecom http://click.libero.it/infostrada11gen07

Dear R-helpers: I have a question related to fitting overdispersed count data using lmer. Basically, I simulate an overdispsed data set by adding an observation-level normal random shock into exp(....+rnorm()). Then I fit a lmer quasipoisson model. The estimation results are very off (see model output of fit.lmer.over.quasi below). Can someone kindly explain to me what went wrong? Many thanks in

Hi, I am performing glm with binomial family and my data show slight overdispersion (HF<1.5). Nevertheless, in order to take into account for this heterogeneity though weak, I use F-test rather than Chi-square (Krackow & Tkadlec, 2001). But surprisingly, outputs of this two tests are exactly similar. What is the reason and how can I scale the output by overdispersion ?? Thank you,

Hi all, I have made an overdispersion test for a data set and get the following result Overdispersion test Obs.Var/Theor.Var Statistic p-value poisson data 16.24267 47444.85 0 after deleting the outliers from the data set I get the following result Overdispersion test Obs.Var/Theor.Var Statistic p-value poisson data 16.27106 0 1 The

Dear All, I am working with linear mixed-effects models using the lme4 package in R. I created a model using the lmer function including some main effects, a three-way interaction and a random effect. Because I work with a binomial and poisson distribution, I want to know whether there is overdispersion in my data or not. Does anybody know how I can retrieve this information from R? Thank you

Hello R-helpers, I would like to fit a non-linear function to data (Discrete X axis, over-dispersed Poisson values on the Y axis). I found the functions gnlr in the gnlm package from Jim Lindsey: this can handle nonlinear regression equations for the parameters of Poisson and negative binomial distributions, among others. I also found the function nls2 in the software package

I am wondering if stepAIC in the MASS library may be used for model selection in an overdispersed Poisson situation. What I thought of doing was to get an estimate of the overdispersion parameter phi from fitting a model with all or most of the available predictors (we have a large number of observations so this should not be problematical) and then use stepAIC with scale = phi. Should this

Hello, I'm a grad student in the Intelligent Transportation Systems lab at Portland State Univ. in Portland, OR, USA. I'm trying to learn the basics of R to run a negative binomial in the near future, and so I ran a test regression on roadway crash data obtained from "Statistical and Econometric Methods for Transportation Data Analysis" by Washington et al (p. 250). I ran the

Dear All I am trying to do a repeated measures analysis using lmer and have a number of issues. I have non-orthogonal, unbalanced data. Count data was obtained over 10 months for three treatments, which were arranged into 6 blocks. Treatment is not nested in Block but crossed, as I originally designed an orthogonal, balanced experiment but subsequently lost a treatment from 2 blocks. My

Dear list, I am needing to extract the estimate of overdispersion (deviance / residual degrees of freedom or c-hat) from multiple model objects - so they can then be used to compare the extent of overdispersion among alternative models as well as calculate qausi-AIC values. I have been unable to do this, despite consulting a number of manuals and searching the R-help. I am imaging that in

Hello! I would like to make a scatterplot of my data, but the problem is that several points have the same x and y values and are represented as only one point. I wonder if there is a way to represent the data points, but with point size representing the frequency of the depicted x-y value? Thank you! -- View this message in context:

I am attempting to run a glm with a binomial model to analyze proportion data. I have been following Crawley's book closely and am wondering if there is an accepted standard for how much is too much overdispersion? (e.g. change in AIC has an accepted standard of 2). In the example, he fits several models, binomial and quasibinomial and then accepts the quasibinomial. The output for residual

dear list! i am running an anlysis on proportion data using binomial (quasibinomial family) error structure. My data comprises of two continuous vars, body size and range size, as well as of feeding guild, nest placement, nest type and foragig strata as factors. I hope to model with these variables the preference of primary forests (#successes) by certain bird species. My code therefore looks