[Gluster-users] NFS file locks

Pavan Sondur
2010-05-13T10:15:01Z

Ian,
Can you send me the whole log file? The trace output captures all locks
granted/blocked etc. Just wanted to analyze the log from the start of the lock
testing session (when you execute locktest.pl) to when the problem is seen.

Pavan
----- Original Message -----
From: "Ian Steinmetz" <Ian_Steinmetz at cable.comcast.com>
To: "Pavan Sondur" <pavan at gluster.com>
Cc: gluster-users at gluster.org, "Shehjar Tikoo" <shehjart at
gluster.com>
Sent: Wednesday, May 12, 2010 10:57:14 PM
Subject: RE: [Gluster-users] NFS file locks

Pavan,

I turned on logging, and ran the perl lockd script again.  Below is the output
during the file locking test.  If I remount the share it reproduces the 1st two
errors over again exactly the same but with different timestamps.

[2010-05-12 12:23:11] N [common.c:375:pl_trace_release] locks: [RELEASE] Lockee
= {ino=1139, fd=0xb5500770, path=/locktest.pl}
[2010-05-12 12:23:12] N [common.c:375:pl_trace_release] locks: [RELEASE] Lockee
= {ino=76, fd=0xb5500770, path=/lockfile}
[2010-05-12 12:23:17] N [common.c:375:pl_trace_release] locks: [RELEASE] Lockee
= {ino=76, fd=0xb5500770, path=/lockfile}
[2010-05-12 12:23:22] N [common.c:375:pl_trace_release] locks: [RELEASE] Lockee
= {ino=76, fd=0xb5500770, path=/lockfile}
[2010-05-12 12:23:27] N [common.c:375:pl_trace_release] locks: [RELEASE] Lockee
= {ino=76, fd=0xb5500770, path=/lockfile}
[2010-05-12 12:23:32] N [common.c:375:pl_trace_release] locks: [RELEASE] Lockee
= {ino=76, fd=0xb5500770, path=/lockfile}
[2010-05-12 12:23:37] N [common.c:375:pl_trace_release] locks: [RELEASE] Lockee
= {ino=76, fd=0xb5500770, path=/lockfile}
[2010-05-12 12:23:42] N [common.c:375:pl_trace_release] locks: [RELEASE] Lockee
= {ino=76, fd=0xb5500770, path=/lockfile}
[2010-05-12 12:23:47] N [common.c:375:pl_trace_release] locks: [RELEASE] Lockee
= {ino=76, fd=0xb5500770, path=/lockfile}
[2010-05-12 12:23:52] N [common.c:375:pl_trace_release] locks: [RELEASE] Lockee
= {ino=76, fd=0xb5500770, path=/lockfile}
[2010-05-12 12:26:39] N [common.c:375:pl_trace_release] locks: [RELEASE] Lockee
= {ino=1139, fd=0xb5500770, path=/locktest.pl}
[2010-05-12 12:26:39] N [common.c:375:pl_trace_release] locks: [RELEASE] Lockee
= {ino=76, fd=0xb5500770, path=/lockfile}
[2010-05-12 12:27:21] N [common.c:375:pl_trace_release] locks: [RELEASE] Lockee
= {ino=76, fd=0xb5500770, path=/lockfile}

--
Ian Steinmetz

-----Original Message-----
From: Pavan Sondur [mailto:pavan at gluster.com]
Sent: Wednesday, May 12, 2010 1:53 AM
To: Steinmetz, Ian
Cc: gluster-users at gluster.org; Shehjar Tikoo
Subject: Re: [Gluster-users] NFS file locks

Ian,
Mandatory locking is not supported in 3.0.x releases. Even if you turn this
option on, it does not
in any way change any locking behavior in GlusterFS. You can perhaps try this,
specifically for locking:

 Turn on an option in the locks translator - 'option trace on'. It
prints debug information about locks which is useful for debugging.

Send us the output and we'll see if a bug needs to be filed. Nevertheless,
we'll try and reproduce it in-house.

Pavan

----- Original Message -----
From: "Ian Steinmetz" <Ian_Steinmetz at cable.comcast.com>
To: "Shehjar Tikoo" <shehjart at gluster.com>
Cc: gluster-users at gluster.org
Sent: Wednesday, May 5, 2010 12:04:52 AM
Subject: Re: [Gluster-users] NFS file locks

Shehjar,

Good catch on the typo, I fixed it an restarted.  Still had the same
issue.  I also was able to get samba working, and file locking seems to
work fine; however, with samba the file owner/group and priv aren't
transferred to clients.  This at least points to an issue with how
NFS/FUSE/GLUSTER are working together.

I'm also searching to see if I can find any other FUSE file systems that
have had similar issues.

--
Ian Steinmetz

-----Original Message-----
From: Shehjar Tikoo [mailto:shehjart at gluster.com]
Sent: Tuesday, May 04, 2010 1:40 AM
To: Steinmetz, Ian
Cc: gluster-users at gluster.org
Subject: Re: [Gluster-users] NFS file locks

Steinmetz, Ian wrote:
> I've turned on debug logging for the server and client of GlusterFS
and
> amended them below.   I've replaced the IP addresses with
"x.x.x" and
> left the last octet for security.  It appears I'm able to lock the
file
> when I run the program directly on the gluster mount point, just not
> when it's mounted via NFS.  I checked and rpc.statd is running.  One
odd
> thing, when I run the perl locking program  directly on the mnt point,
> it appears to work but spits out the following log message:
>
> [2010-05-03 09:16:39] D [read-ahead.c:468:ra_readv] readahead:
> unexpected offset (4096 != 362) resetting

This is nothing to worry about..just debugging output.

.....
.....
.....

>
> [glusterfsd server logfile during above testing]
>
> root at gluster02:/var/log/glusterfs# /usr/sbin/glusterfsd -p
> /var/run/glusterfsd.pid -f /etc/glusterfs/glusterfsd.vol --log-file
> /var/log/glusterfsd.log --debug -N

.....
.....
.....

> Given volfile:
>
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------
> -------+
>   1: volume posix
>   2:   type storage/posix
>   3:   option directory /data/export
>   4: end-volume
>   5:
>   6: volume locks
>   7:   type features/locks
>   8:   option manditory on

I'll continue looking into this but in the mean time you could test over

NFS again with "manditory" changed to "mandatory". Let me
know if that
works.

Thanks
-Shehjar

>   9:   subvolumes posix
>  10: end-volume
_______________________________________________
Gluster-users mailing list
Gluster-users at gluster.org