Pierre Jaury
2016-Oct-16 21:16 UTC
Dict proxy client returning empty string instead of multiline string
Hello,
I am using a dict proxy for my sieve extdata plugin to access some
fields from an SQLite database (autoreply text and other
database-configured items).
All tests are performed against version 2.2.25.
$ dovecot --version
2.2.25 (7be1766)
My configuration looks like:
dict {
sieve = sqlite:/etc/dovecot/pigeonhole-sieve.dict
}
[...]
sieve_extdata_dict_uri = proxy::sieve
I am able to read pretty much any attribute without any issue, except
when the value contains a special character like "\r" or
"\n". By using
the doveadm dict client, I narrowed it down to the dictionary management
part (either server, protocol or client).
I was suspecting escaping functions from "lib/strescape.c" (mostly
str_tabescape and its counterpart, used by "lib-dict/client.c"), so I
monitored socket communications. It seems that escaping is done properly
on the server and the socket is not an issue either.
The following strace dump results from running "doveadm dict get"
against the dict socket:
connect(8, {sa_family=AF_UNIX, sun_path="..."}, 110) = 0
fstat(8, {st_mode=S_IFSOCK|0777, st_size=0, ...}) = 0
[...]
write(8, "H2\t0\t0\tadmin at domain.tld\tsieve\n", 30) = 30
[...]
read(8, "Otest\1r\1ntest\n", 8192) = 14
Indeed "\1r" and "\1n" are the escape sequences used by
"lib/strescape.c". I went deeped and debugged the call to
"dict_lookup"
performed by doveadm. Indeed the client gets the proper string from the
socket and to my surprise, it is properly unescaped.
Then, in "client_dict_lookup" ("lib-dict/dict-client.c"),
the call to
"p_strdup" returns an empty string (null byte set at the target
address).
Before the call to the dict "->lookup" attribute
(client_dict_lookup):
RAX: 0x7ffff73a37c0 (push r14)
RBX: 0x6831b8 ("priv/reply_body")
RCX: 0x7fffffffe240 --> 0x682a60 --> 0x6831b8
("priv/reply_body")
RDX: 0x6831b8 ("priv/reply_body")
RSI: 0x683288 --> 0x7ffff7653120 --> 0x7ffff73ea620 ([...])
RDI: 0x690ad0 --> 0x7ffff7400713 --> 0x75250079786f7270
('proxy')
0x7ffff73a1f10 <dict_lookup+32>: mov rcx,r11 (value_r)
0x7ffff73a1f13 <dict_lookup+35>: mov rdx,r8 (key)
0x7ffff73a1f16 <dict_lookup+38>: mov rsi,r10 (pool)
0x7ffff73a1f19 <dict_lookup+41>: mov rdi,r9 (dict)
0x7ffff73a1f1c <dict_lookup+44>: add rsp,0x8
=> 0x7ffff73a1f20 <dict_lookup+48>: jmp rax
Before the call to p_strdup in "client_dict_lookup":
RSI: 0x6832d8 ("test\r\ntest") (lookup.result.value)
RDI: 0x683288 --> 0x7ffff7653120 --> [...] (pool)
RAX: 0x0 (result)
0x7ffff73a384f: nop
0x7ffff73a3850: mov rsi,QWORD PTR [rsp+0x8]
0x7ffff73a3855: mov rdi,r14
=> 0x7ffff73a3858: call 0x7ffff736d3c0 <p_strdup at plt>
0x7ffff73a385d: mov QWORD PTR [r13+0x0],rax
0x7ffff73a3861: mov rsi,QWORD PTR [rsp+0x18]
0x7ffff73a3866: xor rsi,QWORD PTR fs:0x28
0x7ffff73a386f: mov eax,ebx
After the call:
0x7ffff73a3850: mov rsi,QWORD PTR [rsp+0x8]
0x7ffff73a3855: mov rdi,r14
0x7ffff73a3858: call 0x7ffff736d3c0 <p_strdup at plt>
=> 0x7ffff73a385d: mov QWORD PTR [r13+0x0],rax
0x7ffff73a3861: mov rsi,QWORD PTR [rsp+0x18]
0x7ffff73a3866: xor rsi,QWORD PTR fs:0x28
0x7ffff73a386f: mov eax,ebx
0x7ffff73a3871: jne 0x7ffff73a38da
RSI: 0x0
RDI: 0x6832d8 --> 0x0
RAX: 0x6832d8 --> 0x0 (result)
It is worth noting that I can reproduce the exact same execution flow
with a non-multiline result string (lookup.result.value) that is
properly copied by "p_strdup" and returned in RAX, then displayed by
doveadm.
I am not familiar with the pooling mechanism hidden behind the call to
p_strdump and not quite sure why this behaviour is emerging. Maybe I am
even miles away from an understanding of the issue here, but it sounds
to me like something is wrong in the way "p_strdup" performs the copy.
Hope this helps,
kaiyou.
Pierre Jaury
2016-Oct-16 22:26 UTC
Dict proxy client returning empty string instead of multiline string
I dived a little bit further into the rabbit hole, up to the point where debugging has become unpracticle but I still haven't found the root cause for sure. I read most of the code for "p_strdup" based on datastack memory pools (which are used for dictionary lookups both with doveadm and by extdata) and it seems ok. Still, after "t_malloc_real" is called in "t_malloc0", the allocated buffer has the same address as the source string. The only sensible explanation I can come up with is that during unescaping, strings are not allocated properly, leading to the memory pool reusing the string address and zeroing it in the process before the string copy operation. I will follow on this path tomorrow, any lead is more than welcome. kaiyou. On 10/16/2016 11:16 PM, Pierre Jaury wrote:> Hello, > > I am using a dict proxy for my sieve extdata plugin to access some > fields from an SQLite database (autoreply text and other > database-configured items). > > All tests are performed against version 2.2.25. > > $ dovecot --version > 2.2.25 (7be1766) > > My configuration looks like: > > dict { > sieve = sqlite:/etc/dovecot/pigeonhole-sieve.dict > } > > [...] > sieve_extdata_dict_uri = proxy::sieve > > I am able to read pretty much any attribute without any issue, except > when the value contains a special character like "\r" or "\n". By using > the doveadm dict client, I narrowed it down to the dictionary management > part (either server, protocol or client). > > I was suspecting escaping functions from "lib/strescape.c" (mostly > str_tabescape and its counterpart, used by "lib-dict/client.c"), so I > monitored socket communications. It seems that escaping is done properly > on the server and the socket is not an issue either. > > The following strace dump results from running "doveadm dict get" > against the dict socket: > > connect(8, {sa_family=AF_UNIX, sun_path="..."}, 110) = 0 > fstat(8, {st_mode=S_IFSOCK|0777, st_size=0, ...}) = 0 > [...] > write(8, "H2\t0\t0\tadmin at domain.tld\tsieve\n", 30) = 30 > [...] > read(8, "Otest\1r\1ntest\n", 8192) = 14 > > Indeed "\1r" and "\1n" are the escape sequences used by > "lib/strescape.c". I went deeped and debugged the call to "dict_lookup" > performed by doveadm. Indeed the client gets the proper string from the > socket and to my surprise, it is properly unescaped. > > Then, in "client_dict_lookup" ("lib-dict/dict-client.c"), the call to > "p_strdup" returns an empty string (null byte set at the target address). > > Before the call to the dict "->lookup" attribute (client_dict_lookup): > > RAX: 0x7ffff73a37c0 (push r14) > RBX: 0x6831b8 ("priv/reply_body") > RCX: 0x7fffffffe240 --> 0x682a60 --> 0x6831b8 ("priv/reply_body") > RDX: 0x6831b8 ("priv/reply_body") > RSI: 0x683288 --> 0x7ffff7653120 --> 0x7ffff73ea620 ([...]) > RDI: 0x690ad0 --> 0x7ffff7400713 --> 0x75250079786f7270 ('proxy') > > 0x7ffff73a1f10 <dict_lookup+32>: mov rcx,r11 (value_r) > 0x7ffff73a1f13 <dict_lookup+35>: mov rdx,r8 (key) > 0x7ffff73a1f16 <dict_lookup+38>: mov rsi,r10 (pool) > 0x7ffff73a1f19 <dict_lookup+41>: mov rdi,r9 (dict) > 0x7ffff73a1f1c <dict_lookup+44>: add rsp,0x8 > => 0x7ffff73a1f20 <dict_lookup+48>: jmp rax > > Before the call to p_strdup in "client_dict_lookup": > > RSI: 0x6832d8 ("test\r\ntest") (lookup.result.value) > RDI: 0x683288 --> 0x7ffff7653120 --> [...] (pool) > RAX: 0x0 (result) > > 0x7ffff73a384f: nop > 0x7ffff73a3850: mov rsi,QWORD PTR [rsp+0x8] > 0x7ffff73a3855: mov rdi,r14 > => 0x7ffff73a3858: call 0x7ffff736d3c0 <p_strdup at plt> > 0x7ffff73a385d: mov QWORD PTR [r13+0x0],rax > 0x7ffff73a3861: mov rsi,QWORD PTR [rsp+0x18] > 0x7ffff73a3866: xor rsi,QWORD PTR fs:0x28 > 0x7ffff73a386f: mov eax,ebx > > After the call: > > 0x7ffff73a3850: mov rsi,QWORD PTR [rsp+0x8] > 0x7ffff73a3855: mov rdi,r14 > 0x7ffff73a3858: call 0x7ffff736d3c0 <p_strdup at plt> > => 0x7ffff73a385d: mov QWORD PTR [r13+0x0],rax > 0x7ffff73a3861: mov rsi,QWORD PTR [rsp+0x18] > 0x7ffff73a3866: xor rsi,QWORD PTR fs:0x28 > 0x7ffff73a386f: mov eax,ebx > 0x7ffff73a3871: jne 0x7ffff73a38da > > RSI: 0x0 > RDI: 0x6832d8 --> 0x0 > RAX: 0x6832d8 --> 0x0 (result) > > It is worth noting that I can reproduce the exact same execution flow > with a non-multiline result string (lookup.result.value) that is > properly copied by "p_strdup" and returned in RAX, then displayed by > doveadm. > > I am not familiar with the pooling mechanism hidden behind the call to > p_strdump and not quite sure why this behaviour is emerging. Maybe I am > even miles away from an understanding of the issue here, but it sounds > to me like something is wrong in the way "p_strdup" performs the copy. > > Hope this helps, > kaiyou. > > >
Aki Tuomi
2016-Oct-17 05:51 UTC
Dict proxy client returning empty string instead of multiline string
Hi! This does sound like a bug, we'll have look. Aki On 17.10.2016 01:26, Pierre Jaury wrote:> I dived a little bit further into the rabbit hole, up to the point where > debugging has become unpracticle but I still haven't found the root > cause for sure. > > I read most of the code for "p_strdup" based on datastack memory pools > (which are used for dictionary lookups both with doveadm and by extdata) > and it seems ok. Still, after "t_malloc_real" is called in "t_malloc0", > the allocated buffer has the same address as the source string. > > The only sensible explanation I can come up with is that during > unescaping, strings are not allocated properly, leading to the memory > pool reusing the string address and zeroing it in the process before the > string copy operation. > > I will follow on this path tomorrow, any lead is more than welcome. > > kaiyou. > > On 10/16/2016 11:16 PM, Pierre Jaury wrote: >> Hello, >> >> I am using a dict proxy for my sieve extdata plugin to access some >> fields from an SQLite database (autoreply text and other >> database-configured items). >> >> All tests are performed against version 2.2.25. >> >> $ dovecot --version >> 2.2.25 (7be1766) >> >> My configuration looks like: >> >> dict { >> sieve = sqlite:/etc/dovecot/pigeonhole-sieve.dict >> } >> >> [...] >> sieve_extdata_dict_uri = proxy::sieve >> >> I am able to read pretty much any attribute without any issue, except >> when the value contains a special character like "\r" or "\n". By using >> the doveadm dict client, I narrowed it down to the dictionary management >> part (either server, protocol or client). >> >> I was suspecting escaping functions from "lib/strescape.c" (mostly >> str_tabescape and its counterpart, used by "lib-dict/client.c"), so I >> monitored socket communications. It seems that escaping is done properly >> on the server and the socket is not an issue either. >> >> The following strace dump results from running "doveadm dict get" >> against the dict socket: >> >> connect(8, {sa_family=AF_UNIX, sun_path="..."}, 110) = 0 >> fstat(8, {st_mode=S_IFSOCK|0777, st_size=0, ...}) = 0 >> [...] >> write(8, "H2\t0\t0\tadmin at domain.tld\tsieve\n", 30) = 30 >> [...] >> read(8, "Otest\1r\1ntest\n", 8192) = 14 >> >> Indeed "\1r" and "\1n" are the escape sequences used by >> "lib/strescape.c". I went deeped and debugged the call to "dict_lookup" >> performed by doveadm. Indeed the client gets the proper string from the >> socket and to my surprise, it is properly unescaped. >> >> Then, in "client_dict_lookup" ("lib-dict/dict-client.c"), the call to >> "p_strdup" returns an empty string (null byte set at the target address). >> >> Before the call to the dict "->lookup" attribute (client_dict_lookup): >> >> RAX: 0x7ffff73a37c0 (push r14) >> RBX: 0x6831b8 ("priv/reply_body") >> RCX: 0x7fffffffe240 --> 0x682a60 --> 0x6831b8 ("priv/reply_body") >> RDX: 0x6831b8 ("priv/reply_body") >> RSI: 0x683288 --> 0x7ffff7653120 --> 0x7ffff73ea620 ([...]) >> RDI: 0x690ad0 --> 0x7ffff7400713 --> 0x75250079786f7270 ('proxy') >> >> 0x7ffff73a1f10 <dict_lookup+32>: mov rcx,r11 (value_r) >> 0x7ffff73a1f13 <dict_lookup+35>: mov rdx,r8 (key) >> 0x7ffff73a1f16 <dict_lookup+38>: mov rsi,r10 (pool) >> 0x7ffff73a1f19 <dict_lookup+41>: mov rdi,r9 (dict) >> 0x7ffff73a1f1c <dict_lookup+44>: add rsp,0x8 >> => 0x7ffff73a1f20 <dict_lookup+48>: jmp rax >> >> Before the call to p_strdup in "client_dict_lookup": >> >> RSI: 0x6832d8 ("test\r\ntest") (lookup.result.value) >> RDI: 0x683288 --> 0x7ffff7653120 --> [...] (pool) >> RAX: 0x0 (result) >> >> 0x7ffff73a384f: nop >> 0x7ffff73a3850: mov rsi,QWORD PTR [rsp+0x8] >> 0x7ffff73a3855: mov rdi,r14 >> => 0x7ffff73a3858: call 0x7ffff736d3c0 <p_strdup at plt> >> 0x7ffff73a385d: mov QWORD PTR [r13+0x0],rax >> 0x7ffff73a3861: mov rsi,QWORD PTR [rsp+0x18] >> 0x7ffff73a3866: xor rsi,QWORD PTR fs:0x28 >> 0x7ffff73a386f: mov eax,ebx >> >> After the call: >> >> 0x7ffff73a3850: mov rsi,QWORD PTR [rsp+0x8] >> 0x7ffff73a3855: mov rdi,r14 >> 0x7ffff73a3858: call 0x7ffff736d3c0 <p_strdup at plt> >> => 0x7ffff73a385d: mov QWORD PTR [r13+0x0],rax >> 0x7ffff73a3861: mov rsi,QWORD PTR [rsp+0x18] >> 0x7ffff73a3866: xor rsi,QWORD PTR fs:0x28 >> 0x7ffff73a386f: mov eax,ebx >> 0x7ffff73a3871: jne 0x7ffff73a38da >> >> RSI: 0x0 >> RDI: 0x6832d8 --> 0x0 >> RAX: 0x6832d8 --> 0x0 (result) >> >> It is worth noting that I can reproduce the exact same execution flow >> with a non-multiline result string (lookup.result.value) that is >> properly copied by "p_strdup" and returned in RAX, then displayed by >> doveadm. >> >> I am not familiar with the pooling mechanism hidden behind the call to >> p_strdump and not quite sure why this behaviour is emerging. Maybe I am >> even miles away from an understanding of the issue here, but it sounds >> to me like something is wrong in the way "p_strdup" performs the copy. >> >> Hope this helps, >> kaiyou. >> >> >>
Apparently Analagous Threads
- Dict proxy client returning empty string instead of multiline string
- Dict proxy client returning empty string instead of multiline string
- Dict proxy client returning empty string instead of multiline string
- Dict proxy client returning empty string instead of multiline string
- Dict proxy client returning empty string instead of multiline string