similar to: multi-class modeling

If one estimates a model using multinom, is it possible to perform the omnibus LR test ( the analogue to omnibus F in linear models ) using the output from multinom ? The residual deviance is there but I was hoping I could somehow pull out the deviance based on just using an intercept ? Sample code is below from the CAR book but I wasn't sure how to do it based on that example. Thanks

Dear All: I am interested in multinomial logit models (function multinon, library nnet) but I'm having troubles in choose whether to define the predictors as factors or not. I had posted earlier this example (thanks for the reply ronggui): worms<- data.frame(year= rep(2000:2004, c(3,3,3,3,3)),age=rep(1:3,5),

Hi all, I previously emailed about a multinomial model, and after seeking some additional help, realized that since my response/outcome variables are not mutually exclusive, I need to use a multi-response model that is *not* multinomial. I'm now trying to figure out how to specify the priors on the multi-response model. Any help would be much appreciated. My data look like this: X

Hi, I found that using different contrasts (e.g. contr.helmert vs. contr.treatment) will generate different fitted probabilities from multinomial logistic regression using multinom(); while the fitted probabilities from binary logistic regression seem to be the same. Why is that? and for multinomial logisitc regression, what contrast should be used? I guess it's helmert? here is an example

I want to get the logLik to calculate McFadden.R2 ,ML.R2 and Cragg.Uhler.R2, but the value from multinom does not have logLik.So my quetion is : is logLik meaningful to multinomial logistic model from multinom?If it does, how can I get it? Thank you! ps: I konw VGAM has function to get the multinomial logistic model with logLik, but I prefer use the function from "official" R

Dear all, I have found some difference of the results between multinom() function in R and multinomial logistic regression in SPSS software. The input data, model and parameters are below: choles <- c(94, 158, 133, 164, 162, 182, 140, 157, 146, 182); sbp <- c(105, 121, 128, 149, 132, 103, 97, 128, 114, 129); case <- c(1, 3, 3, 2, 1, 2, 3, 1, 2, 2); result <- multinom(case ~ choles

1. (Mainly) Statistical issues are generally off topic on this list. You might want to try the r-sig-mixed-models list instead. 2. However, I think a better answer is to seek local statistical expertise in order to have an extended discussion about your research intent in order to avoid producing yet more irreproducible psychological research. Cheers, Bert Bert Gunter "The trouble with

Best R Help, I like to estimate a Multinomial Logit Model with 10 Classes. The problem is that the number of observations differs a lot over the 10 classes: Class | num. Observations A | 373 B | 631 C | 171 D | 700 E | 87 F | 249 G | 138 H | 133 I | 162 J | 407 Total: 3051 Where my data looks like: x1 x2 x3 x4 Class 1 1,02 2 1 A 2 7,2 1 5 B 3 4,2 1 4 H 1 4,1 1 8 F 2 2,4 3 7 D 1 1,2 0 4 J 2 0,9

Hi all, I'm working on a multinomial (or "polytomous") logistic regression using R and have made great progress using multinom() from the nnet library. My response variable has three categories, and there are two different possible predictors. I'd like to use the likelihoods of certain models (ie, saturated, fitteds, and null) to calculate Nagelkerke R-squared values for

Running a binary logit model on the data df <- data.frame(y=sample(letters[1:3], 100, repl=T), x=rnorm(100)) reveals some residual deviance: summary(glm(y ~ ., data=df, family=binomial("logit"))) However, running a multinomial model on that data (multinom, nnet) reveals a residual deviance: summary(multinom(y ~ ., data=df)) On page 203, the MASS book says that "here the

Dear all, I'm interested in extracting the score from multinomial logistic regression models fit using multinom, to assess the stregth of assocation of the parameter with the response (akin to the score from clogit/cox regression). currently I'm using R 1.8.1. Is there a function that will extract the score from a multinom object or how i can get back to it? or from using glm? I

Hi, I am trying to specify a multinomial logit model using the multinom function from the nnet package. Now I add another independent variable and it halves the AIC as given by summary(multinom()). But when I call Anova(multinom()) from the car package, it tells me that this added variable is insignificant (Pr(>Chisq)=0.39). Thus, the improved AIC suggests to keep the variable but the Anova

Dear R users, I'm using a multinomial LOGIT model to analyse choice behaviour of consumers (as part of my masters thesis research). Using the R documentation and search on the R website I have a working script now. Parameters are estimated and I can access them via coefficients(multinom.out). In order to see if the parameters are significant I like to access the standard errors in the

Hello all. I am doing one part of an evaluation of a mandatory welfare-to-work programme in the UK. As with all evaluations, the problem is to determine what would have happened if the initiative had not taken place. In our case, we have a number of pilot areas and no possibility of random assignment. Therefore we have been given control areas. My problem is to select for survey individuals in

Hi I am wanting to fit some multinomial logit models (multinom command in package nnet) Is it possible to do any model checking techniques on these models e.g. residual, leverage etc. I cannot seem to find any commands that will allow me to do this. Many thanks ---------------------- L.E.Gross L.E.Gross at maths.hull.ac.uk

Hello, I am VERY new to R (one week) and I am trying to run a multinomial logit model. The model I am using is > model1 <- multinom(Y ~ X1 + X2 + , ..., Xn) if I put in > summary(model1) I get #Error in function (classes, fdef, mtable) : unable to find an inherited method for function "fitted", for signature "multinom" and if I put in > coef(model1)

Dear all, I'm fitting a multinom function to my dataset (multinom(outcome~age+K+D)) and I need to present my results on a poster. Does someone know a nice way of doing that? I think I saw in an archive that you cannot plot a multinom.object, is it true? Thank you by advance for your help, Cheers Camille

Dear R users, Does anyone know if it is possible to use multinom to do a polychotomous fit using one categorical and one numeric variable as response. The doc. for multinom states that for formula , response can be K>2 classes. Is this 2 and more, or as I have understood it only greater than 2. I have tried fitting my data, but have only encountered error messages. On another note, Is it

DeaR useRs: I am looking for a function which fits a multinomial model and in Baron?s page I find the function "multinom" in package "nnet" but this package is deprecated. I suppose that this function is now in other package but I can't find it. Can you help me? Thanks.

Dear everyone, the following problem: Our group has written a lengthy program in c++, to which we would like to add some additional features. Because we are not sure if those features are actually useful, we would prefer to take a "quick and dirty" approach just to try them out. The additional feature is that in every iteration of the algorithm membership-probabilities should by